Center for Anthropocene Studies (CMNH) Internship

Hannah Smith
120 min readSep 27, 2020

This is a live blog that documents the research and design process for the Center for Anthropocene Studies at the Carnegie Museum of Natural History. This blog will document the design process for monthly motion design videos on approved Anthropocene Topics.

*All design projects should take the 5 values of the Center for Anthropocene Studies (CAS) into consideration*

  1. Systems-thinking: Attentive to the interconnections of people and nature; complex dynamics in Earth systems (local ecologies) driven by Human systems (local behaviors and community practices) and the risks and opportunities for human communities and biodiversity that are presented by the problems of the Anthropocene.
  2. Mutual Benefits: Attentive to the creative force of cooperative behavior and symbiosis in the evolution and diversity of life, and in relation to human well-being.
  3. Socially sensitive: Attentive to power inequities and differential experiences among people as part of the environmental science and problem-solving; recognition of the subjectivity of interpretation and the hegemony of Western science and culture; concerned with issues of justice among different people historically, today, and in the future.
  4. Positive human stewardship: Attentive to positive roles of people in nature, nature based problem-solving and providing invitations for publics to connect, collaborate, and take-action.
  5. Interdisciplinarity: Attentive to holistic engagement drawing on multiple forms of knowledge production, including social science, humanities, environmental science, and ecology.

6/04/21 Storyboards Script #3

5/07/21 Storyboards Script #2

5/04/21 Full Video #1 Blocking

Lower Background Audio Version

Full Video in at 3:26, still needs edits and secondary motions

https://vimeo.com/544946299

4/30/21 Video Blocking, Script Audio, and Background Music

Script Audio 1

New Title:

Evolution of fossil fuels in Pennsylvania

Script #1

The industries of petroleum, coal and gas were instrumental in fueling the Great Acceleration starting in the mid 20th century, a time of dramatic increase in human activity and population growth that continues to this day. The Great Acceleration is being debated by scholars as the beginning of the Anthropocene epoch, the proposed geological time period when humans become a dominant force on the planetary system, leaving a global record of impacts in sediments, coral reefs, and glacial ice.

Did you know that Pennsylvania is one of a few states in the U.S. where petroleum, coal and gas are found? And that Pennsylvania was the birthplace of the commercial petroleum industry? How does that history impact Pennsylvania today? And why is that relevant now?

But first: What is Petroleum?

Petroleum is a naturally occurring liquid mixture of hydrocarbons that forms in layers of earth. Petroleum, natural gas and coal are hydrocarbons often referred to as fossil fuels because their formation from decomposed plants and algae took place millions of years ago. Hydrocarbon resources, like petroleum, natural gas and coal, burn very easily, and are widely used for heating, generating electricity, and in motor applications.

To understand Pennsylvania’s evolving use of fossil fuels, we must first understand why Pennsylvania has fossil fuels, and why burning those fuels has negative health, climate and environmental impacts, to understand why the transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy is necessary.

Why does Pennsylvania have fossil fuels?

Let’s travel back into deep-time, to an earlier time on Earth.

From about 490 to 360 million years ago, during what are known as the Ordovician and Devonian geological periods, most of what is now Pennsylvania was an ocean basin teeming with life. In fact, most of North America was under water. Pre-Appalachian Mountains systems eroded over time and deposited sediment of sand, silt, and mud that mixed on the seafloor with the dead plant material. Currents at the ocean bottom were minimal, leaving the accumulating sediments and organic material relatively undisturbed and oxygen-free. Without oxygen, bacteria that normally break down organic material could not act. A thick, black, anoxic ooze formed, preserving the organic material. Over millions of years, forces caused by plate tectonics generated enough heat and pressure to compact the sediments into rock and “cook” the organic material into petroleum. Coal forms slightly differently, from dead plant matter that converts into peat in swamp-like environments. Heat and pressure over millions of years of burying and cooking the water out of the peat, will eventually turn it into coal. Because this process went on below the ocean for almost 200 million years in what is now Pennsylvanian, the state has abundant oil and methane reserves.

How did PA become the birthplace of commercial petroleum? And why did petroleum become a widely used fossil fuel? For this question we need to travel to Titusville, Pennsylvania to meet the “Father of the Petroleum Industry”.

Background Music:

Video Blocking 1

4/27/21 Storyboards

3/5/21

New Video Goals:

  • To educate the general population on the evolution of PA’s energy sources
  • To state the pros and cons of each energy source.

Script Update:

Article Update

The Story of Oil in Western Pennsylvania: What, How, and Why?

I am a fries-on-salad, haluski dinner, dairy farm heritage kind of Western Pennsylvanian. I grew up near Venango and Crawford County and had a rural childhood. I went to a small school with about 300 kids in k-6th grade. Around 4th grade, I remember taking a field trip to Titusville, Pennsylvania. I remember seeing the familiar road signs and buildings as our bus gassed along the back roads. I had family in the Titusville and Oil City area, so it was a common route to take with my parents. I remember thinking, even at that young age, that the area looked dilapidated and just, well, tired. But I was too young to grasp how this tired little town’s geology had changed the global economy and course of human history. When I was older, I pursued a degree in geology and began to understand more about my local community.

Our field trip took us to Titusville Pennsylvania to visit Drake’s Well. Drake’s Well was the first commercial oil well in the United States. It was named after Edwin L. Drake who successfully found and drilled the first oil well for commercial use in 1859 for the Seneca Oil Company, named after the Seneca Indians who were the first people to collect oil in North America by skimming petroleum from the surface of water bodies. The Seneca Indians did not benefit from the Seneca Oil Company and were eventually removed from their native lands in the 1700s and 1800s as settlers moved into their territory. In the early 1800’s oil was an unwanted by-product from salt wells (wells used to mine salt) and before that, a traditional medicine. It was used to treat respiratory diseases, epilepsy, scabies, and other ailments 1. Even today, petrochemicals made from the refining of petroleum are responsible for many of our modern medicines. Ointments, antihistamines, antibacterials, cough syrups, and even aspirin are created from chemical reactions created from petrochemicals 2.

However, the purpose of Drake’s Well was to refine oil for kerosene lamps, to replace the expensive whale oil lamps of the time. While Edwin Drake is accredited for drilling for the first commercial oil well, his journey was wrought with failure. Salt wells used water to dissolve salt source rock, and then carry the water through piping to where it would be evaporated to regular salt, this method works for salt, and less for oil. Oil drilling was a new technology, and because of this, the current technology available from salt well drilling wasn’t exactly compatible for this venture. Edwin Drake had to invent multiple new drilling techniques and procedures, and on August 27, 1859 when his drill reached a depth of 69.5ft, he struck oil in Titusville Pennsylvania. While Drake’s Well was not the most productive, or largest oil well, it was globally significant because it kick-started the petroleum drilling revolution that would eventually change global economies and environments.

Drake had to adapt and develop technologies throughout this drilling process. His most important innovation was the “drive pipe”, a metal pipe used to drill directly into bedrock and keep water away from the drill. While Edwin Drake lived a hard life even after his discovery, he is still considered the father of the modern petroleum practices and industry 3.

When we got to the Drake’s Well Museum I remember seeing an odd looking wooden building with an awkward chimney-like structure on one side. My class was led through single file so we could all get a turn to look at the steel machinery that was used in the drill, and the pipes that dispersed oil into wooden barrels clustered in the building. In my 10 year old brain there is no way I could properly fathom that this discovery was related to many of the comforts and conveniences I took for granted in my life, such as cars, heating, electricity, plastics, medicines, and even the asphalt roads that we drove on. Why was Titusville special? More specifically, why did western Pennsylvania have oil?

From about 490 to 360 million years ago, during what are known as the Ordovician and Devonian geological periods, most of Pennsylvania was an ocean basin teeming with life. As early marine microscopic plants and animals died and fell to the sea floor, they were quickly buried by sediments being eroded from the newly forming Appalachian mountains. Currents at the ocean bottom were minimal, leaving the accumulating sediments and organic material relatively undisturbed and oxygen-free. Without oxygen, bacteria that usually break down organic material could not act. A thick, black, anoxic ooze formed, preserving the organic material. Over millions of years, forces caused by plate tectonics generated enough heat and pressure to compact the sediments into rock and “cook” the organic material into petroleum. If you’re from western Pennsylvania, you’ve probably heard of the Marcellus and Utica shales. The natural gas extracted from these rocks formed in a similar way to petroleum but was subjected to a much longer period of heat and pressure.

With Edwin Drake’s success, Titusville boomed. The same year that Drake started his first oil well, Titusville only had 250 residents. However, by 1865 the population increased to 10,000. Nearby Pithole City, now a ghost town, had 50 hotels during the oil peak of the area. This boom was short lived as other drilling companies came in the area and drilled so much that it lowered the price, losing the momentum that it created in the area, and the companies picked up to look elsewhere almost as quickly as they appeared 5. While Titusville boomed and busted, the oil industry itself was growing by the early 20th century with the increasing widespread use of the electric light bulb and automobiles — both of which relied on fossil fuels. World War I and II relied on increased petroleum consumption, fueling military ships, tanks, and planes. The population explosion of the 1950’s further increased demand for petroleum. Over the course of the 20th century the world’s dependence on oil increased. As of 2016, the world consumed over 97 million barrels daily 6. So what does combusting 97 million barrels of oil a day mean for Earth?

The burning of fossil fuels produces greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, and fluorinated gases. Greenhouse gases absorb heat from the sun that the earth’s surface reflects back out into the atmosphere, similar to how a blanket traps in body heat. Burning fossil fuels causes climate change by increasing the total amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, thickening the “blanket” around the earth, and increasing the global average temperature. According to the IEA (International Energy Agency), in 2019 greenhouse gas CO2 emissions totalled 33 gigatonnes, or 1 billion metric tons, or about 1.5 billion school buses.8 Climate change is responsible for increased frequency and severity of weather disasters, wildfires, and flooding, to name a few. The abundant CO2 in our atmosphere equilibrates with and diffuses into our oceans, causing the water to become more acidic and eroding the calcium carbonate structures of marine organisms, like coral. Climate change does not just affect wildlife, it also affects the lives of Pennsylvanians. In Pennsylvania climate change is likely to lead to increasing home insurance rates, raised taxes to replace infrastructure, longer allergy seasons, increasing heat stroke rates in citizens, rising food costs due to crops damaged by erratic weather and higher temperatures, and decreasing water quality and availability due to large storms causing water contamination.7

Early organisms were buried by sediment 488 to 360 million years ago and altered into petroleum by heat and pressure. For thousands of years, Earth’s petroleum reserves were largely untouched. Innovator Edwin Drake changed petroleum’s role by successfully drilling the first commercial oil well in North America that August day in 1859. Petroleum turned into a global commodity, eventually fueling a fast paced modern life. Now in the 21st century, the burning of fossil fuels, such as petroleum, is causing worldwide rapid climate change, following the boom and bust pattern of the fossil fuel industry.

When I was on that field trip to Drake’s Well in 4th grade, we did not discuss the global or local implications of petroleum. This resource is responsible for many of the day to day conveniences that have come to define contemporary life for many people living on Earth, but it is also feeding an environmental change that is forcing a “new normal”, that will cause an existential threat to humanity. I could not have fathomed that this global resource had its start in my own family’s backyard. I think that Drake’s Well is a good reminder that Earth-changing innovations can happen anywhere. I don’t think Drake could have predicted the scale to which his discovery would change society and the environment over the next 160 years, in the same way that most people do not realize how their small individual actions are affecting the larger social-ecological systems, and sustainability of all life on Earth. Although individual actions can negatively affect Earth, they can also be positive. Who knows, the next innovation to combat anthropogenic climate change may be happening in your backyard.

I started having more appreciation for the Earth Sciences as I got older. This eventually led me to obtaining a bachelor’s degree in geology, interning with the National Park Service at the Hagerman Fossil Beds in Idaho, and working in mapping for a few years before returning to school for illustration and design in hopes to marry the sciences and arts together. While obtaining my geology degree I met my now husband who has a Master’s in Structural Geology, and has worked in the natural gas field for five years before making the switch to environmental geology. Our family’s income was supported by the fossil fuels industry for a time, and therefore we understand a decent amount of the ethics and controversy that is in the industry. However we are both very invested in the earth sciences and look forward to more sustainable tech preserving a better environment for the future.

References:

1 Early Medicinal Uses of Petroleum 2015

https://daily.jstor.org/petroleum-used-medicine/

2 Modern Uses for Petroleum in Medicine 2019

https://context.capp.ca/articles/2019/feature_petroleum-in-real-life_pills

3 Drake’s Well History of Petroleum 2016

https://www.aoghs.org/petroleum-pioneers/american-oil-history/

4 Description of petroleum formation 2014

http://elibrary.dcnr.pa.gov/GetDocument?docId=1752503&DocName=ES8_Oil-Gas_Pa.pdf

5 The boom and bust cycle of the oil industry 2015

https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/23/business/energy-environment/oil-makes-a-comeback-in-pennsylvania.html

6 World Oil Statistics 2016-Current

https://www.worldometers.info/oil/

7 List of the Effects of Climate Change on People and how to protect yourself 2019

https://blogs.ei.columbia.edu/2019/12/27/climate-change-impacts-everyone/

8 International Energy Agency 2019

https://www.iea.org/articles/global-co2-emissions-in-2019

2/23/21 Article Paragraph, Blocking in Video #2, and Storyboard #3

Hannah Smith

History of Petroleum

1/26/21

The Story of Oil in Western Pennsylvania: What, How, and Why?

I am a fries-on-salad, haluski dinner, dairy farm heritage kind of Western Pennsylvanian. I grew up near Venango and Crawford County and had a rural childhood. I went to a small school with about 300 kids in k-6th grade. Around 4th grade, I remember taking a field trip to Titusville, Pennsylvania. I remember seeing the familiar road signs and buildings as our bus gassed along the back roads. I had family in the Titusville and Oil City area, so it was a common route to take with my parents. I remember thinking, even at that young age, that the area looked dilapidated and just, well, tired. But I was too young to grasp how this tired little town’s geology had changed the global economy and course of human history.

Our field trip took us to Titusville Pennsylvania to visit Drake’s Well. Drake’s Well was the first commercial oil well in the United States. It was named after Edwin L. Drake who successfully found and drilled the first oil well for commercial use in 1859 for the Seneca Oil Company, named after the Seneca Indians who were the first people to collect oil in North America by skimming petroleum from the surface of water bodies. The Seneca Indians did not benefit from the Seneca Oil Company and were eventually removed from their native lands in the 1700s and 1800s as settlers moved into their territory. In the early 1800’s oil was an unwanted by-product from salt wells (wells used to mine salt) and before that, a traditional medicine. It was used to treat respiratory diseases, epilepsy, scabies, and other ailments 1. Even today, petrochemicals made from the refining of petroleum are responsible for many of our modern medicines. Ointments, antihistamines, antibacterials, cough syrups, and even aspirin are created from chemical reactions created from petrochemicals 2.

However, the purpose of Drake’s Well was to refine oil for kerosene lamps, to replace the expensive whale oil lamps of the time. While Edwin Drake is accredited for drilling for the first commercial oil well, his journey was wrought with failure. Salt wells used water to dissolve salt source rock, and then carry the water through piping to where it would be evaporated to regular salt, this method works for salt, and less for oil. Oil drilling was a new technology, and because of this, the current technology available from salt well drilling wasn’t exactly compatible for this venture. Edwin Drake had to invent multiple new drilling techniques and procedures, and on August 27, 1859 when his drill reached a depth of 69.5ft, he struck oil in Titusville Pennsylvania. While Drake’s Well was not the most productive, or largest oil well, it was globally significant because it kick-started the petroleum drilling revolution that would eventually change global economies and environments.

Drake had to adapt and develop technologies throughout this drilling process. His most important innovation was the “drive pipe”, a metal pipe used to drill directly into bedrock and keep water away from the drill. While Edwin Drake lived a hard life even after his discovery, he is still considered the father of the modern petroleum practices and industry 3.

When we got to the Drake’s Well Museum I remember seeing an odd looking wooden building with an awkward chimney-like structure on one side. My class was led through single file so we could all get a turn to look at the steel machinery that was used in the drill, and the pipes that dispersed oil into wooden barrels clustered in the building. In my 10 year old brain there is no way I could properly fathom that this discovery was related to many of the comforts and conveniences I took for granted in my life, such as cars, heating, electricity, plastics, medicines, and even the asphalt roads that we drove on. Why was Titusville special? More specifically, why did western Pennsylvania have oil?

The short answer is because most of Pennsylvania used to be covered by an ocean. About 490 to 360 million years ago, known as the Ordovician and Devonian geological periods, most of the continents had combined to create a supercontinent known as Gondwana. However, North America was separated from Gondwana and most of it was covered by ocean. The landmass of early North America (Laurentia) combined with the land mass we know today as Europe in the Devonian to create a Euramerica supercontinent. During the Ordovician and Devonian, the land that would be today Pennsylvania was either completely or partially covered by ocean; and more importantly it was teeming with ocean life. The early invertebrates, corals, fishes, algae and plankton that lived during the Ordovician and Devonian inevitably died and fell to the ocean floor. While this was taking place, the Appalachian mountains that formed out of the ocean in eastern North America during the Ordovician were eroding sediment into western Pennsylvania. The organic debris on the ocean floor was repeatedly covered by the eroding sediment of the mountains causing increased pressure and temperature that would eventually form shale. Shale is a fine grained sedimentary rock with thin layers. These shale rock layers contain petroleum created from the organic debris. If you’re from western Pennsylvania you’ve probably heard of the large fossil fuel producing layers called the Marcellus and Utica shale. This biogeomorphic process described above is how these geologic layers formed and became major sources in the petroleum industry 4.

With Edwin Drake’s success, Titusville boomed. The same year that Drake started his first oil well, Titusville only had 250 residents. However, by 1865 the population increased to 10,000. Nearby Pithole City, now a ghost town, had 50 hotels during the oil peak of the area. This boom was short lived as other drilling companies came in the area and drilled so much that it lowered the price, losing the momentum that it created in the area, and the companies picked up to look elsewhere almost as quickly as they appeared 5. While Titusville boomed and busted, the oil industry itself was growing by the early 20th century with the increasing widespread use of the electric light bulb and automobiles — both of which relied on fossil fuels. World War I increased petroleum consumption, fueling military ships, tanks, and planes. The population explosion of the 1950’s further increased demand for petroleum. Over the course of the 20th century the world’s dependence on oil increased. As of 2016, the world consumed over 97 million barrels daily 6. So what does combusting 97 million barrels of oil a day mean for Earth?

The burning of fossil fuels produces greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, and fluorinated gases. Greenhouse gases absorb heat from the sun that the earth’s surface reflects back out into the atmosphere, similar to how a blanket traps in body heat. Burning fossil fuels causes climate change by increasing the total amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, thickening the “blanket” around the earth, and increasing the global average temperature. According to the IEA (International Energy Agency), in 2019 greenhouse gas CO2 emissions totalled 33 gigatonnes, or 1 billion metric tons, or about 182 million blue whales.8 Climate change is responsible for increased frequency and severity of weather disasters, wildfires, and flooding, to name a few. The abundant CO2 in our atmosphere equilibrates with and diffuses into our oceans, causing the water to become more acidic and eroding the calcium carbonate structures of marine organisms, like coral. Climate change does not just affect wildlife, it also affects the lives of Pennsylvanians. In Pennsylvania climate change is likely to lead to increasing home insurance rates, raised taxes to replace infrastructure, longer allergy seasons, increasing heat stroke rates in citizens, rising food costs due to crops damaged by erratic weather and higher temperatures, and decreasing water quality and availability due to large storms causing water contamination.7

Early organisms were buried by sediment 488 to 360 million years ago and altered into petroleum by heat and pressure. For thousands of years, Earth’s petroleum reserves were largely untouched. Innovator Edwin Drake changed petroleum’s role by successfully drilling the first commercial oil well in North America that August day in 1859. Petroleum turned into a global commodity, eventually fueling a fast paced modern life. Now in the 21st century, the burning of fossil fuels, such as petroleum, is causing worldwide rapid climate change, following the boom and bust pattern of the fossil fuel industry.

When I was on that field trip to Drake’s Well in 4th grade, we did not discuss the global or local implications of petroleum. This resource is responsible for many of the day to day conveniences that have come to define contemporary life for many people living on Earth, but it is also feeding an environmental change that is forcing a “new normal”, that will cause an existential threat to humanity. I could not have fathomed that this global resource had its start in my own family’s backyard. I think that Drake’s Well is a good reminder that Earth-changing innovations can happen anywhere. I don’t think Drake could have predicted the scale to which his discovery would change society and the environment over the next 160 years, in the same way that most people do not realize how their small individual actions are affecting the larger social-ecological systems, and sustainability of all life on Earth. Although individual actions can negatively affect Earth, they can also be positive. Who knows, the next innovation to combat anthropogenic climate change may be happening in your backyard.

[My experience]

[ I grew up in northwestern PA, and have family that live in the Titusville area. Most of my memories from childhood include playing on my grandparents dairy farm with my cousins, and loving to draw. I was also interested in rocks, minerals, and fossils, and that interest continued into adulthood where I eventually received a Bachelor’s degree in Geology from Slippery Rock University. While obtaining my degree, I volunteered in the paleontology department of the Carnegie Museum of Natural History and worked as a Geocorps of America intern with the National Park Service at the Hagerman Fossil Beds in Idaho. I worked in mapping for a few years before I decided to return to school to also obtain an illustration and design degree from Edinboro University, in hopes to marry the sciences and the arts as a career. At SRU, I met my now husband who has a Master’s in Structural Geology from the University of Pittsburgh and has worked in the natural gas field for five years before making the switch to environmental geology. We are both very invested in the earth sciences and look forward to more sustainable tech preserving a better environment for the future. ]

References:

1 Early Medicinal Uses of Petroleum 2015

https://daily.jstor.org/petroleum-used-medicine/

2 Modern Uses for Petroleum in Medicine 2019

https://context.capp.ca/articles/2019/feature_petroleum-in-real-life_pills

3 Drake’s Well History of Petroleum 2016

https://www.aoghs.org/petroleum-pioneers/american-oil-history/

4 Description of petroleum formation 2014

http://elibrary.dcnr.pa.gov/GetDocument?docId=1752503&DocName=ES8_Oil-Gas_Pa.pdf

5 The boom and bust cycle of the oil industry 2015

https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/23/business/energy-environment/oil-makes-a-comeback-in-pennsylvania.html

6 World Oil Statistics 2016-Current

https://www.worldometers.info/oil/

7 List of the Effects of Climate Change on People and how to protect yourself 2019

https://blogs.ei.columbia.edu/2019/12/27/climate-change-impacts-everyone/

8 International Energy Agency 2019

https://www.iea.org/articles/global-co2-emissions-in-2019

[My experience]

[ I grew up in northwestern PA, and have family that live in the Titusville area. Most of my memories from childhood include playing on my grandparents dairy farm with my cousins, and loving to draw. I was also interested in rocks, minerals, and fossils, and that interest continued into adulthood where I eventually received a Bachelor’s degree in Geology from Slippery Rock University. While obtaining my degree, I volunteered in the paleontology department of the Carnegie Museum of Natural History and worked as a Geocorps of America intern with the National Park Service at the Hagerman Fossil Beds in Idaho. I worked in mapping for a few years before I decided to return to school to also obtain an illustration and design degree from Edinboro University, in hopes to marry the sciences and the arts as a career. At SRU, I met my now husband who has a Master’s in Structural Geology from the University of Pittsburgh and has worked in the natural gas field for five years before making the switch to environmental geology. We are both very invested in the earth sciences and look forward to more sustainable tech preserving a better environment for the future. ]

Blocking in Video #2

Storyboards #3

2/19/21 Video Full, Article Edits, Storyboards Video #2

Video Full

Article Edits

So what is oil made from, how did it form, and how did it come to be so prevalent in society? For this story, we can look locally in western Pennsylvania.

The Story of Oil in Western Pennsylvania: What, How, and Why?

I am a fries-on-salad, haluski dinner, dairy farm heritage kind of Western Pennsylvanian. I grew up near Venango and Crawford County and had a rural childhood. I went to a small school with about 300 kids in k-6th grade. Around 4th grade, I remember taking a field trip to Titusville, Pennsylvania. I remember seeing the familiar road signs and buildings as our bus gassed along the back roads. I had family in the Titusville and Oil City area, so it was a common route to take with my parents. I remember thinking, even at that young age, that the area looked dilapidated and just, well, tired. But I was too young to grasp how this tired little town’s geology had changed the global economy and course of human history.

Our field trip took us to Titusville Pennsylvania to visit Drake’s Well. Drake’s Well was the first commercial oil well in the United States. It was named after Edwin L. Drake who successfully found and drilled the first oil well for commercial use in 1859 for the Seneca Oil Company, named after the Seneca Indians who were the first people to collect oil in North America by skimming petroleum from the surface of water bodies. The Seneca Indians did not benefit from the Seneca Oil Company and were eventually removed from their native lands in the 1700s and 1800s as settlers moved into their territory. In the early 1800’s oil was an unwanted by-product from salt wells (wells used to mine salt) and before that, a traditional medicine. It was used to treat respiratory diseases, epilepsy, scabies, and other ailments 1. Even today, petrochemicals made from the refining of petroleum are responsible for many of our modern medicines. Ointments, antihistamines, antibacterials, cough syrups, and even aspirin are created from chemical reactions created from petrochemicals 2.

However, the purpose of Drake’s Well was to refine oil for kerosene lamps, to replace the expensive whale oil lamps of the time. While Edwin Drake is accredited for drilling for the first commercial oil well, his journey was wrought with failure. Salt wells used water to dissolve salt source rock, and then carry the water through piping to where it would be evaporated to regular salt, this method works for salt, and less for oil. Oil drilling was a new technology, and because of this, the current technology available from salt well drilling wasn’t exactly compatible for this venture. Edwin Drake had to invent multiple new drilling techniques and procedures, and on August 27, 1859 when his drill reached a depth of 69.5ft, he struck oil in Titusville Pennsylvania. While Drake’s Well was not the most productive, or largest oil well, it was globally significant because it kick-started the petroleum drilling revolution that would eventually change global economies and environments.

Drake had to adapt and develop technologies throughout this drilling process. His most important innovation was the “drive pipe”, a metal pipe used to drill directly into bedrock and keep water away from the drill. While Edwin Drake lived a hard life even after his discovery, he is still considered the father of the modern petroleum practices and industry 3.

When we got to the Drake’s Well Museum I remember seeing an odd looking wooden building with an awkward chimney-like structure on one side. My class was led through single file so we could all get a turn to look at the steel machinery that was used in the drill, and the pipes that dispersed oil into wooden barrels clustered in the building. In my 10 year old brain there is no way I could properly fathom that this discovery was related to many of the comforts and conveniences I took for granted in my life, such as cars, heating, electricity, plastics, medicines, and even the asphalt roads that we drove on. Why was Titusville special? More specifically, why did western Pennsylvania have oil?

The short answer is because most of Pennsylvania used to be covered by an ocean. About 490 to 360 million years ago, known as the Ordovician and Devonian geological periods, most of the continents had combined to create a supercontinent known as Gondwana. However, North America was separated from Gondwana and most of it was covered by ocean. The landmass of early North America (Laurentia) combined with the land mass we know today as Europe in the Devonian to create a Euramerica supercontinent. During the Ordovician and Devonian, the land that would be today Pennsylvania was either completely or partially covered by ocean; and more importantly it was teeming with ocean life. The early invertebrates, corals, fishes, algae and plankton that lived during the Ordovician and Devonian inevitably died and fell to the ocean floor. While this was taking place, the Appalachian mountains that formed out of the ocean in eastern North America during the Ordovician were eroding sediment into western Pennsylvania. The organic debris on the ocean floor was repeatedly covered by the eroding sediment of the mountains causing increased pressure and temperature that would eventually form shale. Shale is a fine grained sedimentary rock with thin layers. These shale rock layers contain petroleum created from the organic debris. If you’re from western Pennsylvania you’ve probably heard of the large fossil fuel producing layers called the Marcellus and Utica shale. This biogeomorphic process described above is how these geologic layers formed and became major sources in the petroleum industry 4.

With Edwin Drake’s success, Titusville boomed. The same year that Drake started his first oil well, Titusville only had 250 residents. However, by 1865 the population increased to 10,000. Nearby Pithole City, now a ghost town, had 50 hotels during the oil peak of the area. This boom was short lived as other drilling companies came in the area and drilled so much that it lowered the price, losing the momentum that it created in the area, and the companies picked up to look elsewhere almost as quickly as they appeared 5. While Titusville boomed and busted, the oil industry itself was growing by the early 20th century with the increasing widespread use of the electric light bulb and automobiles — both of which relied on fossil fuels. World War I increased petroleum consumption, fueling military ships, tanks, and planes. The population explosion of the 1950’s further increased demand for petroleum. Over the course of the 20th century the world’s dependence on oil increased. As of 2016, the world consumed over 97 million barrels daily 6. So what does combusting 97 million barrels of oil a day mean for Earth?

The burning of fossil fuels produces greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, and fluorinated gases. Greenhouse gases absorb heat from the sun that the earth’s surface reflects back out into the atmosphere, similar to how a blanket traps in body heat. Burning fossil fuels causes climate change by increasing the total amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, thickening the “blanket” around the earth, and increasing the global average temperature. According to the IEA (International Energy Agency), in 2019 greenhouse gas CO2 emissions totalled 33 gigatonnes, or 1 billion metric tons, or about 182 million blue whales.8 Climate change is responsible for increased frequency and severity of weather disasters, wildfires, and flooding, to name a few. The abundant CO2 in our atmosphere equilibrates with and diffuses into our oceans, causing the water to become more acidic and eroding the calcium carbonate structures of marine organisms, like coral. Climate change does not just affect wildlife, it also affects the lives of Pennsylvanians. In Pennsylvania climate change is likely to lead to increasing home insurance rates, raised taxes to replace infrastructure, longer allergy seasons, increasing heat stroke rates in citizens, rising food costs due to crops damaged by erratic weather and higher temperatures, and decreasing water quality and availability due to large storms causing water contamination.7

Early organisms were buried by sediment 488 to 360 million years ago and altered into petroleum by heat and pressure. For thousands of years, Earth’s petroleum reserves were largely untouched. Innovator Edwin Drake changed petroleum’s role by successfully drilling the first commercial oil well in North America that August day in 1859. Petroleum turned into a global commodity, eventually fueling a fast paced modern life. Now in the 21st century, the burning of fossil fuels, such as petroleum, is causing worldwide rapid climate change.

When I was on that field trip to Drake’s Well in 4th grade, we did not discuss the global or local implications of petroleum. This resource is responsible for many of the day to day conveniences that have come to define contemporary life for many people living on Earth, but it is also feeding an environmental change that is forcing a “new normal”, that will cause an existential threat to humanity. I could not have fathomed that this global resource had its start in my own family’s backyard. I think that Drake’s Well is a good reminder that Earth-changing innovations can happen anywhere. I don’t think Drake could have predicted the scale to which his discovery would change society and the environment over the next 160 years, in the same way that most people do not realize how their small individual actions are affecting the larger social-ecological systems, and sustainability of all life on Earth. Although individual actions can negatively affect Earth, they can also be positive. Who knows, the next innovation to combat anthropogenic climate change may be happening in your backyard.

References:

1 Early Medicinal Uses of Petroleum 2015

https://daily.jstor.org/petroleum-used-medicine/

2 Modern Uses for Petroleum in Medicine 2019

https://context.capp.ca/articles/2019/feature_petroleum-in-real-life_pills

3 Drake’s Well History of Petroleum 2016

https://www.aoghs.org/petroleum-pioneers/american-oil-history/

4 Description of petroleum formation 2014

http://elibrary.dcnr.pa.gov/GetDocument?docId=1752503&DocName=ES8_Oil-Gas_Pa.pdf

5 The boom and bust cycle of the oil industry 2015

https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/23/business/energy-environment/oil-makes-a-comeback-in-pennsylvania.html

6 World Oil Statistics 2016-Current

https://www.worldometers.info/oil/

7 List of the Effects of Climate Change on People and how to protect yourself 2019

https://blogs.ei.columbia.edu/2019/12/27/climate-change-impacts-everyone/

8 International Energy Agency 2019

https://www.iea.org/articles/global-co2-emissions-in-2019

Storyboards for Video #2

2/16/21 Video Edits with new Script

2/9/21 Script & Article Updates

Scripts 1–4

History of Petroleum Script #1

What happened to make Pennsylvania the birthplace of the commercial petroleum industry, and why is that relevant now?

Petroleum is a naturally occurring liquid mixture of hydrocarbons that forms in layers of earth. It is processed to create oil, gasoline, and kerosene.

The industries of petroleum, coal and gas were instrumental in fueling the Great Acceleration starting in the mid 20th century, a time of dramatic increase in human activity and growth that continues to this day. The Great Acceleration is being debated by scholars as the beginning of the Anthropocene epoch, which is a time period marked by massive human impact on the planet.

To understand how Petroleum made Pennsylvania a contributing player in the commercial petroleum industry, we must go back into deep-time, to an early Earth. 485–359 million years ago, during the Ordovician and Devonian, the geologic periods responsible for Pennsylvania’s oil reserves, most land on earth was merged into one supercontinent called Gondwana. Most of what we call now, North America, was underwater, separated from Gondwana towards the equator. The current land of Pennsylvania was completely or partially submerged by ocean inhabited by early organisms. How did this early ocean life lead to petroleum? And where is coal and gas in all of this? To answer these questions we need to go deep below the Earth’s surface…

Script #2

What happened to make Pennsylvania the birthplace of the commercial petroleum industry, and why is that relevant now?

Petroleum is a naturally occurring liquid mixture of hydrocarbons that forms in layers of earth. It is processed to create oil, gasoline, and kerosene.

How did early ocean life lead to petroleum? And where is coal and gas in all of this?

During the geologic time periods the Ordovician and Devonian, abundant marine life filled our early oceans. When these organisms died, their bodies fell to the ocean floor, where they were repeatedly covered by eroding sediment and more organic debris. Over time, this increased the temperature and pressure on the dead organisms forming sedimentary rock. With increased heat and pressure, the organic matter turned into hydrocarbons. Hydrocarbons can take the form of either oil or natural gas. Coal forms slightly differently from plant matter in swamp like environments. PA’s geography from almost 500–300 million years ago provided its abundant fossil fuel reserves that are now affecting Earth on a global scale. How did PA become the birthplace of commercial petroleum? For this question we need to travel to Titusville, Pennsylvania to meet the “Father of the Petroleum Industry”.

Script #3

What happened to make Pennsylvania the birthplace of the commercial petroleum industry, and why is that relevant now?

Petroleum is a naturally occurring liquid mixture of hydrocarbons that forms in layers of earth. It is processed to create oil, gasoline, and kerosene.

Who is the “Father of the Commercial Petroleum Industry”?

Let’s start at the beginning of petroleum use in North America. Petroleum was originally used for medicinal purposes by the Seneca Indians of North America. It was also an unwanted by-product of salt wells in the 1800s. Before petroleum use, lamps were fueled by expensive whale fat. It was discovered that by refining petroleum he could create kerosene, a cheap and clean burning fuel for lamp oil, causing a need for petroleum. The Seneca Oil Company, named for the Seneca Indians, hired train conductor Edwin L. Drake to find petroleum around Titusville PA. Edwin failed repeatedly over the course of 5 months, having to innovate and experiment to learn how to drill for petroleum. Eventually he created the “drive pipe”, a pipe that would drill directly into bedrock keeping the water away from the drill, allowing petroleum to rise. On August 27th, 1859, at the depth of 69.5ft, Edwin L. Drake, successfully drilled for oil and gave birth to the commercial oil drilling industry, in what is now known as Drake’s Well.

Today petroleum is used for electricity, fuel, plastics, chemical, and pharmaceutical productions. It is a commodity used in the day to day of many peoples lives, but in this time of widespread human impact on the environment, how is this widespread use affecting Pennsylvania?

Script #4

What happened to make Pennsylvania the birthplace of the commercial petroleum industry, and why is that relevant now?

Petroleum is a naturally occurring liquid mixture of hydrocarbons that forms in layers of earth. It is processed to create oil, gasoline, and kerosene.

Petroleum and other fossil fuels are commodities used for day to day life in Pennsylvania, but how is this widespread use affecting the state?

The Anthropocene is our current time period used to describe how human activity is having a profound effect on the planet, marked by radioactive debris in the geologic rock layers. Petroleum is a fossil fuel, the burning of fossil fuels creates greenhouse gases, which in turn absorb heat from the sun in our atmosphere, slowly releasing it over time, heating up our planet. Climate change will affect Pennsylvanians by, damaging homes, increasing insurance costs, raising taxes to replace infrastructure for climate change, increasing allergies and health risks such as longer allergy seasons and stroke, more expensive food, from crops being damaged by storms and warmer temperatures, decreasing water quality from storms causing water contamination, and decreasing the available drinkable water on our planet. However, the global and statewide trend towards renewables is offering energy options outside of fossil fuels. Currently, Pennsylvania has 27 wind farms producing enough power for 350,000 homes. It also has 19,000 solar installations, and growing, across the state. The expanding renewable energy sector in Pennsylvania is proof that humans can adapt and evolve our technologies for the betterment of the planet.

Article Update ver. 6

So what is oil made from, how did it form, and how did it come to be so prevalent in society? For this story, we can look locally in western Pennsylvania.

I am a fries on salad, haluski dinner, dairy farm heritage kind of Western Pennsylvanian. I grew up near Venango and Crawford County and had a pretty rural childhood. I went to an equally rural small school with about 300 kids in a k-6th grade school. Probably around 4th grade, I remember taking a field trip to Titusville PA. I remember seeing the familiar road signs and buildings as our bus gassed along the back roads. I had family in the Titusville and Oil City area, so it was a common route to take with my parents. If I’m being honest, I always remembered thinking that the area looked dilapidated and just, well tired. But at that point I was too young to know how this town’s geologic resources had affected the environment and economy on a global scale.

On that particular occasion we were heading to Titusville PA to visit Drake’s Well. Drake’s Well was the first commercial oil well in the United States. It was named after Edwin L. Drake who successfully found and drilled the first oil well for commercial use in 1859 for the Seneca Oil Company, named after the Seneca Indians who were the first people to collect oil in North America by skimming surface petroleum from water bodies. The Seneca Indians did not benefit from the Seneca Oil Company and were eventually removed from their native lands in the 1700s and 1800s as settlers moved into their territory. In the early 1800’s oil was an unwanted by-product from salt wells (wells used to mine salt) and before that, a traditional medicine. It was used to treat respiratory diseases, hysteria, epilepsy, scabies, and other ailments 1. Even today, petrochemicals made from the refining of petroleum are responsible for many of our modern medicines. Ointments, antihistamines, antibacterials, cough syrups, and even aspirin are created from chemical reactions created from petrochemicals 2.

However, the purpose of Drake’s Well was to refine oil for kerosene lamps, to replace the expensive whale oil lamps of the time. While Edwin Drake is accredited for drilling for the first commercial oil well, his journey was wrought with failure. Salt wells used water to dissolve salt source rock, and then carry the water through piping to where it would be evaporated to regular salt, this method works for salt, and less for oil. Oil drilling was a new technology, and because of this, the current technology available from salt well drilling wasn’t exactly compatible for this venture. Edwin Drake had to invent multiple new drilling techniques and procedures, and on August 27, 1859 when his drill reached a depth of 69.5ft, he struck oil in Titusville Pennsylvania. While Drake’s Well was not the most productive, or largest oil well, it was globally significant because it kick started the petroleum drilling revolution that would eventually change global economies and environments. Edwin had to adapt and develop technologies throughout this drilling process. His most important innovation was the “drive pipe”, a metal pipe used to drill directly into bedrock and keep water away from the drill. While Edwin Drake lived a hard and poor life even after his discovery, he is still considered the father of the modern petroleum practices and industry 3.

When we got to the Drake’s Well Museum I remember seeing an odd looking wooden building with an awkward chimney-like structure on one side. My class was led through single file so we could all get a turn to look at the steel machinery that was used in the drill, and the pipes that dispersed oil into wooden barrels clustered in the building. In my 10 year old brain there is no way I could properly fathom that this discovery was related to many of the comforts and conveniences I took for granted in my life, such as cars, heating, electricity, plastics, medicines, and even the asphalt roads that we drove on. Why was Titusville special? More specifically, why did western Pennsylvania have oil?

The short answer is because most of Pennsylvania used to be covered by ocean. During the geologic time periods of the Ordovician and Devonian, about 488 mya — 443 mya (million years ago) and 419 mya — 359 mya respectively, most of the continents had combined to create a supercontinent known as Gondwana. However, North America was separated from Gondwana and most of it was covered by ocean. The landmass of early North American (Laurentia) combined with the land mass we know today as Europe in the Devonian to create a Euramerica supercontinent. During the Ordovician and Devonian, the land that would be today Pennsylvania was either completely or partially covered by ocean; and more importantly it was teeming with ocean life. The early invertebrates, corals, fishes, algae and plankton that lived during the Ordovician and Devonian inevitably died and fell to the ocean floor. While this was taking place, the Appalachian mountains that formed out of the ocean in eastern North America during the Ordovician were eroding sediment into western PA. The organic debris on the ocean floor was repeatedly covered by the eroding sediment of the mountains causing increased pressure and temperature that would eventually form shale. Shale is a fine grained sedimentary rock with thin laminations. These shale rock layers contain petroleum created from the organic debris. If you’re from western PA you’ve probably heard of the large fossil fuel producing layers the Marcellus and Utica shale. This biogeomorphic process described above is how these geologic layers formed and became major sources in the petroleum industry 4.

With Edwin Drake’s success, Titusville boomed. The same year that Drake started his first oil well, Titusville only had 250 residents. However, by 1865 the population increased to 10,000. Nearby Pithole City, now a ghost town, had 50 hotels during the oil peak of the area. This boom was short lived as other drilling companies came in the area and drilled so much that it lowered the price, losing the momentum that it created in the area, and the companies picked up to look elsewhere almost as quickly as they appeared 5. While Titusville boomed and busted, the oil industry itself was growing by the early 20th century with the increasing widespread use of the electric light bulb and automobiles. World War I also caused an increase in petroleum consumption, fueling military ships, tanks, and planes. The population explosion of the 1950’s also increased the need for petroleum. Over the course of the 20th century the world dependence on oil has increased. As of 2016, the world consumed 97,103,871 barrels daily 6. So what does 97 million barrels of oil a day look like for Earth?

Petroleum is a fossil fuel, the burning of fossil fuels produces greenhouse gases. Greenhouse gases absorb heat from the sun and slowly release it over time, increasing temperatures and climate change across the planet. According to the EPA, in 2014 greenhouse gas emissions totalled 15.1 trillion pounds.8 Climate change is responsible for increased weather disasters, wildfires, and flooding. The abundant CO2 in our atmosphere also seeps into our oceans, causing the water to become more acidic and eroding the shells of our ocean’s shelled organisms. Climate change does not just affect wildlife, it will also affect the lives of local Pennsylvanians. Pennsylvania residents will experience climate change including, but not limited to, increasing home insurance rates, raised taxes to replace infrastructure, longer allergy seasons, increasing heat stroke rates in citizens, rising food costs due to crops damaged by erratic weather and higher temperatures, and decreasing water quality and availability due to large storms causing water contamination.7

Early organisms were buried by sediment 488 to 360 million years ago and altered into petroleum by heat and pressure. For thousands of years, Earth’s petroleum reserves were largely untouched, as early people primarily used surfaced oil for medicinal purposes. Innovator Edwin L. Drake changed petroleum’s role by successfully drilling the first commercial oil well in North America that August day in 1859. Petroleum turned into a global commodity, eventually fueling a fast paced modern life. Now in the 21st century, the burning of fossil fuels, such as petroleum, has caused an abundance of greenhouse gases causing worldwide climate change.

When I was on that field trip to Drake’s Well in 4th grade, we did not discuss the global or local implications of petroleum. This resource is responsible for the day to day conveniences that allow the modern world to exist, but it is also feeding an environmental phenomenon that will eventually force a “new normal”, whether good or bad, onto the inhabitants of Earth. I could not have fathomed that this global resource had its start in my own family’s backyard. I think that Drake’s Well is a good reminder that new innovations can happen anywhere; innovations that have the potential to affect the entire Earth. I don’t think Edwin could have predicted the scale to which his discovery would proliferate over the next 160 years, in the same way that most people do not realize how their small individual actions are affecting the sustainability of life on Earth. But while individual actions can negatively affect Earth, they can also be positive. Who knows, the next innovation that can benefit the environment may be happening in your backyard.

References:

1 Early Medicinal Uses of Petroleum

https://daily.jstor.org/petroleum-used-medicine/

2 Modern Uses for Petroleum in Medicine

https://context.capp.ca/articles/2019/feature_petroleum-in-real-life_pills

3 Drake’s Well History of Petroleum

https://www.aoghs.org/petroleum-pioneers/american-oil-history/

4 Description of petroleum formation

http://elibrary.dcnr.pa.gov/GetDocument?docId=1752503&DocName=ES8_Oil-Gas_Pa.pdf

5 The boom and bust cycle of the oil industry

https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/23/business/energy-environment/oil-makes-a-comeback-in-pennsylvania.html

6 World Oil Statistics

https://www.worldometers.info/oil/

7 List of the Effects of Climate Change on People and how to protect yourself https://blogs.ei.columbia.edu/2019/12/27/climate-change-impacts-everyone/

8 EPA Climate Change Indicators

https://www.epa.gov/climate-indicators/climate-change-indicators-us-greenhouse-gas-emissions

2/2/21 Script Updates

Script #3

Who is the “Father of the Commercial Petroleum Industry”?

Let’s start at the beginning of petroleum use in North America. Petroleum was originally used for medicinal purposes by the Seneca Indians of North America, followed by being labeled as an unwanted by-product of salt wells in the 1800s. Before petroleum use, lamps were fueled by expensive whale fat. Chemist Abraham Gesner, discovered that by refining petroleum he could create kerosene, a cheap and clean burning fuel for lamp oil, causing a need for petroleum. The Seneca Oil Company, named for the Seneca Indians, hired train conductor Edwin L. Drake to find petroleum around Titusville PA. Edwin failed repeatedly over the course of 5 months, having to innovate and experiment to learn how to drill for petroleum. Eventually he created the “drive pipe”, a pipe that would drill directly into bedrock keeping water away from the drill. On August 27th, 1859, at the depth of 69.5ft, Edwin L. Drake, successfully drilled for oil and gave birth to the commercial oil drilling industry, in what is now known as Drake’s Well.

Today petroleum is used for electricity, fuel, plastics, chemical, and pharmaceutical productions. It is a commodity used in the day to day of many peoples lives, but how is this widespread use affecting us?

Script #4

How is the widespread use of petroleum affecting us?

Petroleum is a fossil fuel, the burning of fossil fuels creates greenhouse gases, which in turn absorb heat from the sun in our atmosphere, slowly releasing it over time, heating up our planet. Currently, 97 million barrels of oil a day, about 36 billion barrels of oil a year’s worth of greenhouse gases are added to our atmosphere due to human activity. This heating causes wildfires, flooding, and increased natural weather disasters. The greenhouse gas CO2, also seeps into our oceans causing “ocean acidification”, where the increasingly acidic ocean water degrades the shells of marine life. Climate change will also affect people by, damaging homes, increasing insurance costs, raising taxes to replace infrastructure for climate change, increasing allergies and health risks such as longer allergy seasons and stroke, more expensive food, from crops being damaged by storms and warmer temperatures, decreasing water quality from storms causing water contamination, and decreasing the available drinkable water on our planet.

1/26/21 Script, Article, Schedule Update

Script #1 Update

Petroleum is a naturally occurring liquid mixture of hydrocarbons that forms in layers of earth. It is used to create oil, gasoline, and kerosene.

What happened to make Pennsylvania the birthplace of the commercial petroleum industry, and why is that relevant now?

The industries of petroleum, coal and gas were instrumental in fueling the Great Acceleration starting in the mid 20th century, a time of dramatic increase in human activity and growth that continues to this day. The Great Acceleration is being debated by scholars as the beginning of the Anthropocene epoch, which is a time period marked by massive human impact on the planet.

To understand how Petroleum made Pennsylvania a contributing player in the Anthropocene, we must go back into deep-time, to an early Earth. 485–359 million years ago, during the Ordovician and Devonian, the geologic periods responsible for Pennsylvania’s oil reserves, most land on earth was merged into one supercontinent called Gondwana. Most of what we call now, North America, was underwater, separated from Gondwana towards the equator. The current land of Pennsylvania was completely or partially submerged by ocean inhabited by early organisms. How did this early ocean life lead to petroleum? And where is coal and gas in all of this? The next video will cover how fossil fuels were created in Pennsylvania.

Script #2

During the geologic time periods the Ordovician and Devonian, abundant marine life filled our early oceans. When these organisms died, their bodies fell to the ocean floor, where they were repeatedly covered by eroding sediment and more organic debris. Over time, this increased the temperature and pressure on the dead organisms forming sedimentary rock. With increased heat and pressure, the organic matter turned into hydrocarbons. Hydrocarbons can take the form of either oil or natural gas. Coal forms slightly differently from plant matter in swamp like environments. It is this hundreds of millions of years process that creates the fossil fuels that we are using now in our current Anthropocene time period, a time when humans have a massive impact on our environment. PA’s geography from almost 500–300 million years ago provided its abundant fossil fuel reserves, but how did PA become the birthplace of commercial petroleum?

Schedule (tentative)

Article Update #4

History of Petroleum

Despite the confusing logo of Sinclair gas stations, you are not filling up your gas tank with dinosaurs. So what is oil made from, how did it form, and how did it come to be so prevalent in society? For this story, we can look locally in western Pennsylvania.

I am a fries on salad, haluski dinner, dairy farm heritage kind of Western Pennsylvanian. I grew up near Venango and Crawford County and had a pretty rural childhood. I went to an equally rural small school with about 300 kids in a k-6th grade school. Probably around 4th grade, I remember taking a field trip to Titusville PA. I remember seeing the familiar road signs and buildings as our bus gassed along the back roads. I had family in the Titusville and Oil City area, so it was a common route to take with my parents. If I’m being honest, I always remembered thinking that the area looked dilapidated and just, well tired. But at that point I was too young to know how this town’s geologic resources had affected the environment and economy on a global scale.

On that particular occasion we were heading to Titusville PA to visit Drake’s Well. Drake’s Well was the first commercial oil well in the United States. It was named after Edwin L. Drake who successfully found and drilled the first oil well for commercial use in 1859 for the Seneca Oil Company, named after the Seneca Indians who were the first people to collect oil in North America by skimming surface petroleum from water bodies. The Seneca Indians did not benefit from the Seneca Oil Company and were eventually removed from their native lands in the 1700s and 1800s as settlers moved into their territory. In the early 1800’s oil was an unwanted by-product from salt wells (wells used to mine salt) and before that, a traditional medicine. It was used to treat respiratory diseases, hysteria, epilepsy, scabies, and other ailments. Even today, petrochemicals made from the refining of petroleum are responsible for many of our modern medicines. Ointments, antihistamines, antibacterials, cough syrups, and even aspirin are created from chemical reactions created from petrochemicals.

However, the purpose of Drake’s Well was to refine oil for kerosene lamps, to replace the expensive whale oil lamps of the time. While Edwin Drake is accredited for drilling for the first commercial oil well, his journey was wrought with failure. Salt wells used water to dissolve salt source rock, and then carry the water through piping to where it would be evaporated to regular salt, this method works for salt, and less for oil. Oil drilling was a new technology, and because of this, the current technology available from salt well drilling wasn’t exactly compatible for this venture. Edwin Drake had to invent multiple new drilling techniques and procedures, and on August 27, 1859 when his drill reached a depth of 69.5ft, he struck oil in Titusville Pennsylvania. While Drake’s Well was not the most productive, or largest oil well, it was globally significant because it kick started the petroleum drilling revolution that would eventually change global economies and environments. Edwin had to adapt and develop technologies throughout this drilling process. His most important innovation was the “drive pipe”, a metal pipe used to drill directly into bedrock and keep water away from the drill. While Edwin Drake lived a hard and poor life even after his discovery, he is still considered the father of the modern petroleum practices and industry.

When we got to the Drake’s Well Museum I remember seeing an odd looking wooden building with an awkward chimney-like structure on one side. My class was led through single file so we could all get a turn to look at the steel machinery that was used in the drill, and the pipes that dispersed oil into wooden barrels clustered in the building. In my 10 year old brain there is no way I could properly fathom that this discovery was related to many of the comforts and conveniences I took for granted in my life, such as cars, heating, electricity, plastics, medicines, and even the asphalt roads that we drove on. Why was Titusville special? More specifically, why did western Pennsylvania have oil?

The short answer is because most of Pennsylvania used to be covered by ocean. During the geologic time periods of the Ordovician and Devonian, about 488 mya — 443 mya (million years ago) and 419 mya — 359 mya respectively, most of the continents had combined to create a supercontinent known as Gondwana. However, North America was separated from Gondwana and most of it was covered by ocean. The landmass of early North American (Laurentia) combined with the land mass we know today as Europe in the Devonian to create a Euramerica supercontinent. During the Ordovician and Devonian, the land that would be today Pennsylvania was either completely or partially covered by ocean; and more importantly it was teeming with ocean life. The early invertebrates, corals, fishes, algae and plankton that lived during the Ordovician and Devonian inevitably died and fell to the ocean floor. While this was taking place, the Appalachian mountains that formed out of the ocean in eastern North America during the Ordovician were eroding sediment into western PA. The organic debris on the ocean floor was repeatedly covered by the eroding sediment of the mountains causing increased pressure and temperature that would eventually form shale. Shale is a fine grained sedimentary rock with thin laminations. These shale rock layers contain petroleum created from the organic debris. If you’re from western PA you’ve probably heard of the large fossil fuel producing layers the Marcellus and Utica shale. This biogeomorphic process described above is how these geologic layers formed and became major sources in the petroleum industry.

With Edwin Drake’s success, Titusville boomed. The same year that Drake started his first oil well, Titusville only had 250 residents. However, by 1865 the population increased to 10,000. Nearby Pithole City, now a ghost town, had 50 hotels during the oil peak of the area. This boom was short lived as other drilling companies came in the area and drilled so much that it lowered the price, losing the momentum that it created in the area, and the companies picked up to look elsewhere almost as quickly as they appeared. While Titusville boomed and busted, the oil industry itself was growing by the early 20th century with the increasing widespread use of the electric light bulb and automobiles. World War I also caused an increase in petroleum consumption, fueling military ships, tanks, and planes. The population explosion of 1950, The Great Acceleration, also increased the need as there were more people consuming than ever. Over the course of the 20th century the world dependence on oil has increased. As of 2016, the world consumed 97,103,871 barrels every day. Even with the slight decrease in oil usage during 2020 Covid, 2021 is expected to return to these levels. So what does 97 million barrels of oil a day look like for Earth?

Petroleum is a fossil fuel, the burning of fossil fuels produces greenhouse gases. Greenhouse gases absorb heat from the sun and slowly release it over time, increasing temperatures and climate change across the planet. Currently, 97 million barrels of oil a day, 35.5 billion barrels of oil a year’s worth of greenhouse gasses. Climate change is responsible for increased larger weather disasters, increasing wildfires, and flooding. The abundant CO2 in our atmosphere also seeps into our oceans, causing the water to become more acidic and eroding the shells of our ocean’s shelled organisms. Climate change does not just affect wildlife, here are a few way that climate change will directly affect people:

  • Damaging homes, making home insurance more expensive
  • Raising taxes, infrastructure will need to be replaced for climate change
  • Increasing allergies and health risks, warmer air causing longer allergy seasons and heat stroke
  • More expensive food, increased storms damaging crops and warmer temperatures causing increased food spoilage and plant diseases
  • Decreasing water quality, large storms causing water contamination

488 to 360 million years ago, early organisms were buried by sediment and altered into petroleum by heat and pressure. For thousands of years, Earth’s petroleum reserves were largely untouched, as early people primarily used surfaced oil for medicinal purposes. Innovator Edwin L. Drake changed petroleum’s role by successfully drilling the first commercial oil well in North America that August day in 1859. Petroleum turned into a global commodity, eventually fueling a fast paced modern life. Now in the 21st century, the burning of fossil fuels, such as petroleum, has caused an abundance of greenhouse gases causing worldwide climate change.

When I was on that field trip to Drake’s Well in 4th grade, we did not discuss the global implications of petroleum. This resource is responsible for the day to day conveniences that allow the modern world to exist, but it is also feeding an environmental phenomenon that will eventually force a “new normal”, whether good or bad, onto the inhabitants of Earth. I could not have fathomed that this global resource had its start in my own family’s backyard. I think that Drake’s Well is a good reminder that new innovations can happen anywhere; innovations that have the potential to affect the entire Earth. I don’t think Edwin could have predicted the scale to which his discovery would proliferate over the next 160 years, in the same way that most people do not realize how their small individual actions are affecting the sustainability of life on Earth.

https://www.aoghs.org/petroleum-pioneers/american-oil-history/

https://ucmp.berkeley.edu/devonian/devonian.php

https://ucmp.berkeley.edu/ordovician/ordotect.html

https://carnegiemnh.org/research/anthropocene/

http://ib.berkeley.edu/labs/barnosky/Zalasiewicz%20et%20al%20QI2015.pdf

https://futureearth.org/2015/01/16/the-great-acceleration/

https://www.drakewell.org/about-us/site-history

https://daily.jstor.org/petroleum-used-medicine/

https://www.aoghs.org/petroleum-discoveries/

https://ucmp.berkeley.edu/ordovician/ordovician.php

https://ucmp.berkeley.edu/devonian/devonian.php

http://elibrary.dcnr.pa.gov/GetDocument?docId=1752503&DocName=ES8_Oil-Gas_Pa.pdf

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/shale

https://ektinteractive.com/history-of-oil/

https://www.prb.org/humanpopulation/

https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/climate-change-atmospheric-carbon-dioxide

https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/world-population-by-year/

https://www.yourtango.com/2018313744/best-environmental-quotes-save-the-earth

https://www.enopetroleum.com/oildiscoveries.html

https://www.thirteen.org/wnet/extremeoil/history/prehistory.html

https://www.encyclopedia.com/environment/energy-government-and-defense-magazines/edwin-l-drake-strikes-oil-titusville-pennsylvania

http://history.alberta.ca/energyheritage/oil/pre-modern-global-history/early-human-pre-industrial-history/default.aspx#page-2

https://context.capp.ca/articles/2019/feature_petroleum-in-real-life_pills

https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/oil-and-petroleum-products/use-of-oil.php

http://www.saltinstitute.org/content/download/9072/49165/file/Solution%20Mining%20for%20Salt.pdf

https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/theymadeamerica/whomade/drake_hi.html

https://www.pabook.libraries.psu.edu/literary-cultural-heritage-map-pa/feature-articles/edwin-drake-and-oil-well-drill-pipe

https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/23/business/energy-environment/oil-makes-a-comeback-in-pennsylvania.html

https://www.worldometers.info/oil/

https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/oil-demand-outlook-2021-covid-19-vaccine-iea-forecasts-2020-11-1029795224

https://blogs.ei.columbia.edu/2019/12/27/climate-change-impacts-everyone/

1/18/21 Script & Article Update & Music Update

Music Update

In our last meeting it had been mentioned that I should find different background music. Here are some that I found.

If you click on the link, and go to AShamaluevMusic you can see all of their background music pieces. The current song is “Among the Stars”, I am suggesting: (on the Instrumental Background Music for Vimeo playlist)

9. Inspirational Moment

25. Purpose

30. Success

56. Past

134. Documentary Soundtrack

183. Emotional Cinematic Ambient

199. Epic Inspiration

214. Serious Documentary

219. Documentary Piano

224. Cinematic Ambient

265. Documentary

Script Update #1

Petroleum is a naturally occurring liquid mixture of hydrocarbons that forms in layers of earth. It is used to create oil, gasoline, and kerosene.

What happened to make Pennsylvania the birthplace of the commercial petroleum industry, and why is that relevant now?

The industries of petroleum, coal and gas were instrumental in fueling the Great Acceleration starting in the mid 20th century, a time of dramatic increase in human activity and growth that continues to this day. The Great Acceleration is being debated by scholars as the beginning of the Anthropocene epoch, which is a time period marked by massive human impact on the planet.

To understand how Petroleum made Pennsylvania a contributing player in the Anthropocene, we must go back into deep-time, to an early Earth. 485–359 million years ago, during the Ordovician and Devonian, the geologic periods responsible for Pennsylvania’s oil reserves, most land on earth was merged into one supercontinent called Gondwana. Most of what we call now, North America, was underwater, separated from Gondwana towards the equator. The current land of Pennsylvania was completely or partially submerged by ocean inhabited by early organisms. How did this early ocean life lead to petroleum? And where is coal and gas in all of this?

Script #2

During the geologic time periods the Ordovician and Devonian, abundant marine life filled our early oceans. When these organisms died, their bodies fell to the ocean floor, where they were repeatedly covered by eroding sediment and more organic debris. Over time, this increased the temperature and pressure on the dead organisms forming sedimentary rock. With increased heat and pressure, the organic matter turned into hydrocarbons. Hydrocarbons can take the form of either oil or natural gas. Coal forms slightly differently from plant matter in swamp like environments. It is this hundreds of millions of years process that creates the fossil fuels that we are using now in our current Anthropocene time period, a time when humans have a massive impact on our environment. PA’s geography from almost 500–300 million years ago provided its abundant fossil fuel reserves, but how did PA become the birthplace of commercial petroleum?

Article Update

I am a fries on salad, haluski dinner, dairy farm heritage kind of Western Pennsylvanian. I grew up near Venango and Crawford County and had a pretty rural childhood. I went to an equally rural small school with about 300 kids in a k-6th grade school. Probably around 4th grade, I remember taking a field trip to Titusville PA. I remember seeing the familiar road signs and buildings as our bus gassed along the back roads. I had family in the Titusville and Oil City area, so it was a common route to take with my parents. If I’m being honest, I always remembered thinking that the area looked dilapidated and just, well tired. But at that point I was too young to know how this town’s geologic resources had affected the environment and economy on a global scale.

On that particular occasion we were heading to Titusville PA to visit Drake’s Well. Drake’s Well was the first commercial oil well in the United States. It was named after Edwin L. Drake who successfully found and drilled the first oil well for commercial use in 1859 for the Seneca Oil Company, named after the Seneca Indians who used petroleum for medicinal purposes since the 1400s. The Seneca Indians were the first people to collect oil in North America and would skim surfaced petroleum from water bodies. The Seneca Indians did not benefit from the Seneca Oil Company and were eventually removed from their native lands in the 1700s and 1800s as settlers moved into their territory. Today we think of oil as a commodity for transportation and production, but it’s early use was completely unrelated. In the early 1800’s oil was an unwanted by-product from salt wells and before that, a traditional medicine. Native Americans and early peoples from around 980AD collected oil from natural oil seeps for medicinal purposes. There is even evidence of people drilling for oil with bamboo poles in China as early as 347AD. It was used to treat respiratory diseases, hysteria, epilepsy, scabies, and other ailments. Even today, petrochemicals made from the refining of petroleum are responsible for many of our modern medicines. Ointments, antihistamines, antibacterials, cough syrups, and even aspirin are created from chemical reactions created from petrochemicals. However, the purpose of Drake’s Well was to refine oil for kerosene lamps, to replace the expensive whale oil lamps of the time. While Edwin Drake is accredited for drilling for the first commercial oil well, his journey was wrought with failure. Oil drilling was a new technology, and because of this, the current technology available from salt well drilling wasn’t exactly compatible for this venture. Even though Edwin Drake invented multiple new drilling techniques and procedures, he failed to locate oil for 5 months straight. Drake was considered crazy and lost credibility with most of his crew. It wasn’t until August 27, 1859 when his drill reached a 69.5 ft. depth, that he struck oil in Titusville Pennsylvania. While Drake’s Well was not the most productive, or largest oil well, it was globally significant because it kick started the petroleum drilling revolution that would change global economies and environments. While Edwin Drake lived a hard and poor life even after his discovery, he is still considered the father of the modern petroleum practices and industry.

When we got to the Drake’s Well Museum I remember seeing an odd looking wooden building with an awkward chimney-like structure on one side. My class was led through single file so we could all get a turn to look at the steel machinery that was used in the drill, and the pipes that dispersed oil into wooden barrels clustered in the building. In my 10 year old brain there is no way I could properly fathom that this discovery was related to many of the comforts and conveniences I took for granted in my life, such as cars, heating, electricity, plastics, medicines, and even the asphalt roads that we drove on. Why was Titusville special? More specifically, why did western Pennsylvania have oil?

The short answer is because most of Pennsylvania used to be covered by ocean. During the geologic time periods of the Ordovician and Devonian, about 488 mya — 443 mya and 419 mya — 359 mya respectively, most of the continents had combined to create a supercontinent known as Gondwana. However, North America was separated from Gondwana and most of it was covered by ocean. The landmass of early North American (Laurentia) combined with the land mass we know today as Europe in the Devonian to create a Euramerica supercontinent. During the Ordovician and Devonian, the land that would be today Pennsylvania was either completely or partially covered by ocean; and more importantly it was teeming with ocean life. The early invertebrates, corals, fishes, algae and plankton that lived during the Ordovician and Devonian inevitably died and fell to the ocean floor. While this was taking place, the Appalachian mountains that formed out of the ocean in eastern North America during the Ordovician were eroding sediment into western PA. The organic debris on the ocean floor was repeatedly covered by the eroding sediment of the mountains causing increased pressure and temperature that would eventually form shale. Shale is a fine grained sedimentary rock with thin laminations. These shale rock layers contain petroleum created from the organic debris. Ever heard of the Marcellus Shale? The Utica Shale? This biogeomorphic process described above is how these geologic layers formed and became major sources in the petroleum industry.

  • ASK ASIA ABOUT WHAT TO FOCUS ON HERE*

Video Comp.

I made the underwater continents more blue as discussed and created an outline for PA and made its color match the other continents.

Since the animations will depend highly on the script and audio I am waiting on those confirmations to finish up timing and animations.

1/12/21 Video Update, Script #2, Storyboard #2

Video Update

https://vimeo.com/499660566

Script#2 draft #1(How Petroleum, Coal, & Natural Gas form)

During the geologic time periods the Ordovician and Devonian, abundant marine life filled our early oceans. When these organisms died, their bodies fell to the ocean floor, where they were repeatedly covered by eroding sediment and more organic debris. Over time, this increased the temperature and pressure on the dead organisms forming sedimentary rock. With increased heat and pressure, the organic matter turned into hydrocarbons. Hydrocarbons can take the form of either oil or natural gas. Coal forms slightly differently from plant matter in swamp like environments. It is this hundreds of millions of years process that creates the fossil fuels that we are using now in our current Anthropocene time period, a time when humans have a massive impact on our environment. PA’s geography from almost 500–300 million years ago provided its abundant fossil fuel reserves, but how did PA become the birthplace of commercial petroleum?

Storyboard #2 draft #1

1/08/21 Video Basic Draft

Here is the basic draft for the first video. You can tell that areas still need finessed and secondary animations need to be added, but it gives you the basic idea for how the video will look.

1/06/21 Script and Storyboard Update

Script#1

What happened to make Pennsylvania the birthplace of petroleum, and why is that relevant now?

The industries of petroleum, coal and gas were instrumental in fueling the Great Acceleration starting in the mid 20th century, a time of dramatic increase in human activity and growth that continues to this day. The Great Acceleration is being debated by scholars as the beginning of the Anthropocene epoch, which is a time period marked by massive human impact on the planet.

To understand how Petroleum made Pennsylvania a contributing player in the Anthropocene, we must go back into deep-time, to an early Earth. 485–359 million years ago, during the Ordovician and Devonian, the geologic periods responsible for Pennsylvania’s oil reserves, most land on earth was merged into one supercontinent called Gondwana. Most of what we call now, North America, was underwater, separated from Gondwana towards the equator. The current land of Pennsylvania was completely or partially submerged by ocean inhabited by early organisms. How did this early ocean life lead to petroleum? And where is coal and gas in all of this?

Storyboard

1/06/21 Article & Script Update & New Style Design Video

For today’s meeting, I want to focus on the script with Asia Ward. Once a script is set in stone, the I can confidently proceed with video development in it’s entirety. I tried to direct a narrower focus in the article like Asia suggested in her edits and tried to include stewardship and after effect ideas into each phase of video outlines instead of making them their own video.

Script 1 Update:

Pennsylvania is the birthplace of modern petroleum. It is deeply integrated into all parts of our daily lives. But where does petroleum come from?

Earth is at least 4.6 billion years old. Early earth was fiery and gaseous. As the planet cooled, crusts formed, and the planet’s first life emerged. Oxygen appeared in large amounts for the first time, geologic plates began to subduct, and early corals appeared. The geologic periods the Ordovician and Devonian are responsible for Pennsylvania’s oil reserves. While most land was a part of the supercontinent Gondwana near Antarctica; Laurentia (North America) was almost completely covered by ocean near the equator. During these time periods, Pennsylvania was completely or partially submerged by ocean inhabited by early organisms. How did this early ocean life lead to petroleum?

Phase 1: Geologic History of PA

This video should cover more plate tectonics than what I stated previously. I think we should talk about cover the the geologic periods until the Devonian which is the time periods necessary to talk about petroleum layers. End when introduce ocean life.

Phase 2: Formation of Petroleum in PA

Start with ocean life, and how the high organics of the Ordovician and Devonian layers formed petroleum. A brief description of how petroleum is formed.

Phase 3: Early Petroleum History

Start with early uses, and evolve into the events of Drake’s Well.

Phase 4: Petroleum Explosion

Why and how petroleum expanded and how it improved the quality of life. Also how it led to climate change.

Article Update

I am a fries on salad, haluski dinner, dairy farm heritage kind of Western Pennsylvanian. I grew up near Venango and Crawford County and had a pretty rural childhood. I went to an equally rural small school with about 300 kids in a k-6th grade school. Probably around 4th grade, I remember taking a field trip to Titusville PA. I remember seeing the familiar road signs and buildings as our bus gassed along the back roads. I had family in the Titusville and Oil City area, so it was a common route to take with my parents. If I’m being honest, I always remembered thinking that the area looked dilapidated and just, well tired. But at that point I was too young to know how this town’s geologic resources had affected the environment and economy on a global scale.

On that particular occasion we were heading to Titusville PA to visit Drake’s Well. Drake’s Well was the first commercial oil well in the United States. It was named after Edwin L. Drake (who was only a train conductor at the time) who successfully found and drilled the first oil well for commercial use in 1859 for the Seneca Oil Company (now known as ExxonMobil). Today we think of oil as a commodity for transportation and production, but it’s early use was completely unrelated. In the early 1800’s oil was an unwanted by-product from salt wells and before that, a traditional medicine. Native Americans and early peoples from around 980AD collected oil for medicinal purposes. It was used to treat respiratory diseases, hysteria, epilepsy, scabies, etc. Historical documentation shows that it was even used to treat mange in livestock. However, the purpose of Drake’s Well was to refine oil for kerosene lamps, to replace the expensive whale oil lamps of the time. While Edwin Drake had successfully proven that oil could be drilled for, he failed. A lot. Oil drilling was a new concept, and because of this, the current technology wasn’t exactly compatible for this venture. Even though Edwin Drake invented multiple new drilling techniques and procedures, he still could not locate oil for 5 months straight. Drake was considered crazy and lost the credibility of most of his crew. It wasn’t until August 27, 1859 when his drill reached a 69.5 ft. depth, that he struck oil in Titusville Pennsylvania. While Drake’s Well was not the most producing, or largest oil well, it was important because it kick started the petroleum drilling revolution that would change our global economies and environment. While Edwin Drake lived a hard and poor life even after his discovery, he is still considered the father of the modern petroleum practices and industry.

When we got to the Drake’s Well Museum I remember seeing an odd looking wooden building with an awkward chimney-like structure on one side. My class was led through single file so we could all get a turn to look at the steel machinery that was used in the drill, and the pipes that dispersed oil into wooden barrels clustered in the building. In my 10 year old brain there is no way I could properly fathom that this discovery was the reason why I had most of my modern day comforts and conveniences. Why was Titusville special? More specifically, why did western Pennsylvania have this oil?

The short answer is because Pennsylvania used to be covered by ocean. During the geologic time periods of the Ordovician and Devonian, about 488 mya — 443 mya and 419 mya — 359 mya respectively, most of the continents had combined to create a supercontinent known as Gondwana. However, North America was separated from Gondwana and most of it was covered by ocean. Early North American (Laurentia) combined with Europe in the Devonian to create a Euramerica supercontinent. During the Ordovician and Devonian Pennsylvania was either completely or partially covered by ocean; and more importantly ocean life. The early invertebrates, corals, fishes, algae and plankton, alive during the Ordovician and Devonian inevitably died and fell to the ocean floor. While this was taking place, the Appalachian mountains were eroding sediment into western PA. The organic debris on the ocean floor was repeatedly covered by the eroding sediment of the mountains causing increased pressure and temperature that would eventually form the thinly laminated fine grained sedimentary rock shale. These shale rock layers now contain hydrocarbon created from the organic debris that can be drilled for petroleum. Ever heard of the Marcellus Shale? The Utica Shale? This is how both of these geologic layers formed and became major players in the petroleum industry.

But how did a collection of dead fish rock and lamp oil change our global economy and environment? There are a couple factors to this. The first was that petroleum was more flexible in its uses than coal, and had a larger variety of applications. The second and third was the increasingly widespread use of the electric light bulb and automobile in the early 20th century. Eventually, around 1920, gasoline outsold the lamp oil kerosene and the need for petroleum was evident. Living standards increased with our new technology, farming and public health practices, all fueled by oil. In the mid 20th century life became easier due to our new technology from petroleum. It wasn’t so much that there were that many new births, more so that less people were dying (however, birth rates did increase after World War I and II). But the primary driving force was that petroleum made life easier for everyone causing a longer life span.

The Anthropocene is the geologic time period where humans have a prominent effect on the Earth and its processes. How does this relate to petroleum usage? Well, less people are dying, the population is growing, and a good proportion of them are using the technology and conveniences given to them by fossil fuels. What does the burning of fossil fuels produce? Carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. Greenhouse gases absorb heat and slowly release it over time, causing increased temperatures and climate change across our planet as well as more frequent and larger natural weather disasters. The effects of greenhouse gases and climate change are widespread throughout my planet, and they are all connected. Earth had a human population of 2 billion in 1900. This has almost tripled to about 7.8 billion in 2020. Earth still has the same finite resources, and modern humans are still trying to live the easiest lifestyle provided to us by our technology.

When I was on that field trip to Drake’s Well in 4th grade I had no idea of the global implications that this commodity had created. I could not have fathomed that this global super powered resource had its start in my own family’s backyard.

trying to think of a good conclusion paragraph added to this ^

“You cannot protect the environment unless you empower people, you inform them, and you help them understand that these resources are their own, that they must protect them.” — Wangari Maathai

New additional sources

https://www.aoghs.org/petroleum-pioneers/american-oil-history/

https://ucmp.berkeley.edu/devonian/devonian.php

https://ucmp.berkeley.edu/ordovician/ordotect.html

New Video Style

I wasn’t pleased with paper images I was creating for the video and I got an idea in the eleventh hour before this meeting. I recently got a new drawing app Adobe Fresco on my iPad. I decided to try to make simple textured paintings on there to then animate in After Effects. This was me trying this style instead, while still retaining the paper texture effect and drop shadows. I am pleased with this style and I think this is what I will pursue with for the final videos. I like the large amount of texture the combination of the two creates.

The process I used was water color and chalk brushes, and then created each object on different layers so that they can be individually animated in After Effects. I think the primary animation effect I will carry through the videos will be how I did the gas around early earth. For that effect I drew two separate frames of gas and alternated between the two. I think this will help with the stop motion aesthetic I was attracted to for these. To help with this, I also lowered the frame rate from 29 to 23 for the video. I may lower it even more.

12/31/20 Script Update

History of Petroleum in PA Part 1 Script:

The Anthropocene is the current geologic period where humans have a substantial effect on Earth’s systems and processes. In the time of the Anthropocene we must see that all things are connected.

Petroleum has had a large influential effect on the world. We use it for everything from heating our homes to powering our cars. But where does petroleum come from?

Earth is at least 4.6 billion years old. We know this because of dated meteorites that were found on the Earth’s surface. The first geologic eon was the fiery and gaseous Hadean. Then there was the Archean, when our crusts cooled and our planet’s first life appeared. Oxygen appeared in large amounts in the Proterozoic for the first time, geologic plates began to subduct, and early corals appeared. After the Proterozoic eon, there were the Ordovician and Devonian periods. The events of these time periods are the reason for the petroleum preserves that PA produces. During these time periods western PA was submerged by ocean with abundant organisms. The early invertebrate life, algae, plankton, corals, and fishes would die and fall to the ocean floor. This organic matter was then covered by sediment eroding from the Appalachian Mountains. With the repeated burial of the organic matter by eroded sediment and additional dead organisms, heat and pressure would push on the rock layers creating shale and the organic matter stored in the shale would turn into petroleum. This is how the big petroleum players of Pennsylvania the Utica Shale, and Marcellus Shale, formed.

12/28/20 Update on History of Petroleum and the Anthropocene

  1. Here is what I’ve been working on over winter break. The first week I focused on my article on the The History of Petroleum & The Anthropocene. I tried to remember everything that we had talked about when I wrote my first article during development. I also tried to make the Anthropocene a larger piece in this article. I included my own wester PA experiences, the history of petroleum, a description of The Anthropocene and the Great Acceleration, why PA has oil, and how it oil is now affecting our environment. I found three different quotes that I liked at the end, I figured we will talk about them at our next meeting.

I am a fries on salad, almost hit a deer every time I drive, haluski dinner, dairy farm heritage kind of Western Pennsylvanian. I grew up near Venango and Crawford County and had a pretty rural childhood. I went to an equally rural small school with about 300 kids in a k-6th grade school. My grade school years were pretty uneventful as far as normal childhoods go. Pizza days were awesome, sparkly stickers adorned worksheets, and field trips were king. Probably around 4th grade, I remember taking a field trip to Titusville PA. I remember seeing the familiar road signs and buildings as our bus gassed along the back roads. I had family in the Titusville and Oil City area, so it was a common route to take with my parents. If I’m being honest, I always remembered thinking that the area looked dilapidated and just, well tired. But at that point I was too young to know how this town’s geologic resources had affected the environment and economy on a global scale.

The Anthropocene is defined as the current geologic epoch where humans have a profound impact on the functioning of Earth’s planetary systems. There is some debate as to when the Anthropocene began, but there is some consensus that it began around the 1950’s with the Great Acceleration. The Great Acceleration was the point in the mid-20th century where human activity/growth drastically increased, having a large effect on the Earth’s processes. From the 1950’s to present, multiple graphs charting the sharp increase of things such as population, GDP, energy use, and water use can be correlated with the drastic increase of CO2, surface temperature, ocean acidification, forest loss, etc. Let me give an example of what happened in the Great Acceleration. Let’s say there are 100 people in an environment. These 100 people are consuming fossil fuels for their homes, transportation, and buying food grown with modern farming practices. While there is an affect on the environment, it is so far pretty minimal. Now let’s say in just a few decades the population has grown to 1,000 people, who are all living the same lifestyle as the original 100 in the same sized environment. How does this new influx of population affect our environment? Now that these important terms have been explained, let’s continue our field trip.

On that particular occasion we were heading to Titusville PA to visit Drake’s Well. For adults not from western PA and oblivious past 4th graders like me, Drake’s Well was the first commercial oil well in the United States. It was named after Edwin L. Drake (who was only a train conductor at the time) who successfully found and drilled the first oil well for commercial use in 1859 for the Seneca Oil Company (now known as ExxonMobil). Most of the history of oil before this time was anything but the transportation and production commodity that we see it as today. In the early 1800’s oil was an unwanted by-product from salt wells and before that, a traditional medicine used for hundreds of years for anything from respiratory problems to scabies. Even in the 1840’s, Pittsburgh native, Samuel Kier began selling oil by-product from his salt wells as a pain treatment. With his success he opened oil refineries in Pittsburgh to manufacture “Kier’s genuine petroleum!”. The purpose of Drake’s Well was also different from my modern assumptions, it was to refine oil for kerosene lamps, to replace the expensive whale oil lamps of the time. While Edwin Drake had successfully proven that oil could be drilled for, he failed. A lot. Drake was considered crazy and lost credibility with most of his crew. Oil drilling was a new concept, and because of this, the current technology wasn’t exactly compatible for this venture. Even though Edwin Drake invented multiple new drilling techniques and procedures, he still could not locate oil for 5 months straight. It wasn’t until August 27, 1859 when his drill reached a 69.5 ft. depth, that he struck oil in Titusville Pennsylvania. While Drake’s Well was not the most producing, or largest oil well, it was important because it kick started the petroleum drilling revolution that would change our global economies and environment. While Edwin Drake lived a hard and poor life even after his discovery, he is still considered the father of the modern petroleum practices and industry.

When we got to the Drake’s Well Museum I remembered seeing an odd looking wooden building with an awkward chimney-like structure on one side. My class was led through single file so we could all get a turn to look at the steel machinery that was used in the drill, and the pipes that dispersed oil into wooden barrels clustered in the building. In my 10 year old brain there is no way I could properly fathom that this discovery was the reason why I had most of my modern day comforts and conveniences. Titusville was also just another usual place for me, so it didn’t seem that special of a location at the time. But why was Titusville special? More specifically, why did western Pennsylvania have this oil?

The short answer is because Pennsylvania used to be covered by ocean. During the geologic time periods of the Ordovician and Devonian, about 488 mya - 443 mya and 419 mya - 359 mya respectively, western Pennsylvania was covered by ocean and more importantly ocean life. The early invertebrates, corals, fishes, algae and plankton, alive during the Ordovician and Devonian would inevitably die and fall to the ocean floor. While this was taking place, the Appalachian mountains were eroding sediment into western PA. The organic debris on the ocean floor was repeatedly covered by the eroding sediment of the mountains causing increased pressure and temperature that would eventually form the thinly laminated fine grained sedimentary rock shale. These shale rock layers now contain hydrocarbon created from the organic debris that can be drilled for petroleum. Ever heard of the Marcellus Shale? The Utica Shale? This is how both of these geologic layers formed and became major players in the petroleum industry.

But how did a collection of dead fish rock and lamp oil change our global economy and environment? There are a couple factors to this. The first was that petroleum was more flexible in its uses than coal, and had a larger variety of applications. The second and third was the increasingly widespread use of the electric light bulb and automobile in the early 20th century. Eventually, around 1920, gasoline outsold the lamp oil kerosene and the need for petroleum was evident. Living standards increased with our new technology, farming and public health practices, all fueled by oil. Do you remember the Great Acceleration and the Anthropocene that I brought up earlier? When did those begin? That’s right, mid 20th century. When life became easier due to our new technology from petroleum, it wasn’t so much that there were that many new births, more so that less people were dying (however, birth rates did increase after World War I and II). But the primary driving force was that petroleum made life easier for everyone causing a falling death rate. Less people dying, more available technology, what’s the catch?

Let’s define the Anthropocene again. The Anthropocene is the geologic time period where humans have a prominent effect on the Earth and its processes. How does this relate to petroleum usage? Well, less people are dying, the population is growing, and a good proportion of them are using the technology and conveniences given to them by fossil fuels. What do fossil fuels produce? Carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. Greenhouse gases absorb heat and slowly release it in time, causing increased temperatures and climate change across our planet as well as more frequent and larger weather natural disasters. But that’s not all, carbon dioxide also gets absorbed by our oceans, where it creates carbonic acid, eroding the shells of our marine life. This decreases the food supply for some of our fish stocks that are already stressed from their large scale harvesting by petroleum fueled fishing trolleys. And of course plants absorb carbon dioxide, but while we’re creating high amounts of CO2 in our atmosphere we are also destroying our carbon sink forests faster than ever with petroleum fueled machinery for meat and palm oil production. The effects of greenhouse gases and climate change are widespread throughout my planet, and they are all connected. My actions, and the actions of my fellow citizens of Earth are single handedly causing the destruction of the Earth’s natural processes and the attributes of our planet that made it inhabitable to us in the first place.

Let me start by saying that I am not anti fossil fuels, which may sound odd after my last paragraph. I think the problem is bigger than that. Do you remember my example about the community with 100 people jumping to 1,000 all trying to live the same lifestyle with the same amount of resources? Well our Earth is like that, except it’s more like a population of 2 billion in 1900 to a population that has almost tripled to about 7.8 billion in 2020. We still have the same finite resources, and we’re still trying to live the easiest lifestyle provided to us by our technology. I don’t blame petroleum or fossil fuels initially for its effect on our life, it served its purpose and provided a substantial increase in our quality of life. I think the problem now is, we know better, yet we continue to push the same technology using the same fossil fuels and the same “solutions” after all this time and proof that this isn’t fixing our imminent problem. I as an inhabitant of Earth I need to look inward and really think about how my actions are affecting my planet. I need to see less putting the economy before our planet, when there will be no economy if my planet dies. I need to be a passionate innovator like Edwin Drake who evolved and created new technology to pursue his goal, all while fighting against the judgement of his colleagues.

When I was on that field trip to Drake’s Well in 4th grade I had no idea of the global implications that this commodity had created. I was just excited about the shiny rocks at the gift shop...I especially could not have fathomed that this global super powered resource had its start in my own family’s backyard. But I’m older now, and I know better, and I also know now that a global change can happen anywhere. The next energy revolution is on the horizon in your own backyard.

Today I leave you with the words of Sir. David Attenborough and Carl Sagan,

“The truth is, the natural world is changing. And we are totally dependent on that world. It provides our food, water, and air. It is the most precious thing we have and we need to defend it.” - Sir. David Attenborough

“Anything else you’re interested in is not going to happen if you can’t breathe the air or drink the water. Don’t sit this one out. Do something.” - Carl Sagan.

“You cannot protect the environment unless you empower people, you inform them, and you help them understand that these resources are their own, that they must protect them.” - Wangari Maathai

https://carnegiemnh.org/research/anthropocene/

http://ib.berkeley.edu/labs/barnosky/Zalasiewicz%20et%20al%20QI2015.pdf

https://futureearth.org/2015/01/16/the-great-acceleration/

https://www.drakewell.org/about-us/site-history

https://daily.jstor.org/petroleum-used-medicine/

https://www.aoghs.org/petroleum-discoveries/

https://ucmp.berkeley.edu/ordovician/ordovician.php

https://ucmp.berkeley.edu/devonian/devonian.php

http://elibrary.dcnr.pa.gov/GetDocument?docId=1752503&DocName=ES8_Oil-Gas_Pa.pdf

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/shale

https://ektinteractive.com/history-of-oil/

https://www.prb.org/humanpopulation/

https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/climate-change-atmospheric-carbon-dioxide

https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/world-population-by-year/

https://www.yourtango.com/2018313744/best-environmental-quotes-save-the-earth

2. This is my progress on the video stylizations that I did for week two. My husband and I did some engineering with our camera and the ceiling to figure out an optimal stop motion layout for the paper scenes. I also obtained a cricket, and got a stockpile of different card stock. I tried two different versions. The first version was using After Effects entirely while trying to create a paper stop motion like look. The second version was using straight stop-motion that can later have modifications in After Effects. I also worked on the script for the first video.

I have also decided on the background music for the videos.

“Among the Stars” by AShamaluevMusic on Patreon.

My Ceiling Camera

*Nikon 3200*

(we are currently waiting for a mini hdmi cord in the mail that will allow me to watch a live feed of my images as I’m animating)

The paper bounty

Cricut

I am learning the software right now and having a few issues but nothing that shouldn’t clear up with some more practice

Motion Test 1: After Effects (Everything done on the computer)

This is about a 10 second motion test to see if I can create a stop motion paper effect entirely on the computer.

Stop Motion Set up

It took awhile to get the logistics for this and to get everything in the mail. But I have the basic premise and we can get an idea of style difference between it and the entirely Motion Graphics motion test.

History of Petroleum in PA Part 1 Script:

The Anthropocene is the current geologic period where humans have a substantial effect on Earth’s systems and processes. In the time of the Anthropocene we must see that all things are connected.

PA natives know that petroleum has had a large influential effect on our state. But how did Pennsylvanian petroleum influence the world? And how did it get there in the first place?

Earth is at least 4.6 billion years old. We know this because of dated meteorites that were found on the Earth’s surface. The first geologic eon was the fiery and gaseous Hadean. Then there was the Archean, when our crusts cooled and our planet’s first life appeared. Oxygen appeared in large amounts in the Proterozoic for the first time, geologic plates began to subduct, and early corals appeared. After the Proterozoic eon, there were the Ordovician and Devonian periods. The events of these time periods are the reason for the petroleum preserves that PA produces. During these time periods western PA was submerged by ocean with abundant organisms. The early invertebrate life, algae, plankton, corals, and fishes would die and fall to the ocean floor. This organic matter was then covered by sediment eroding from the Appalachian Mountains. With the repeated burial of the organic matter by eroded sediment and additional dead organisms, heat and pressure would push on the rock layers creating shale and the organic matter stored in the shale would turn into petroleum. This is how the big petroleum players of Pennsylvania the Utica Shale, and Marcellus Shale, formed.

12/8/20 History of Petroleum Outline

Phase 1: Geologic History of PA

  • Earth created ~4.6bya (known because of dated meteorites)
  • The firey, gaseous, Hadean period 4.4–4.2bya
  • The cooling crusts and the appearance of first life in the Archean 4.2bya-2500mya (stromatolites)
  • The presence of oxygen in large amounts Proterozoic 2500mya-541mya (BIFS, subduction, ~40% of c.crust today, corals)
  • Phanerozoic 541mya-present, evolution of diverse life, supercontinents, leads into…
  • …the evolution of PA (sea level elevation fluctuation, formation of Appalachian mountains, petroleum, coal formations, natural gas in PA)

Rough Storyboards Phase 1:

Phase 2: Formation of Petroleum in PA

  • PA under sea level in Ordovician-Devonian, high organics led to natural gas and petroleum deposition.
  • organic matter in sedimentary rocks, with deposition, heat, pressure, and time, creates petroleum source rocks
  • reservoirs, porosity, permeability, stratigraphy, def. petroleum
  • Lower sea level in Miss.-Penn. led to anoxic swamp environments that led to the development of coal reserves

Phase 3: Early Petroleum History

  • Native American medicinal purposes, lamps, agricultural avoidance
  • by product of salt wells, sold as snake oil Samuel Kier 1849, eventually lead to refining for lighting
  • PA Rock Oil Company-hired Edwin Drake to drill for oil in western PA (Drake had no qualifications, but became president of the new/renamed Seneca Oil Company, followed by multiple failures).
  • Drake funded himself to dig and found an oil reservoir on Aug 27, 1859 at only 69ft. Drake’s Well/first commercial petroleum extraction
  • With no patent or land, Drake was out of the industry just as it was exploding

Phase 4: Petroleum Explosion

  • Titusville, Oil City, Pithole, population boom
  • First year, well’s produced 4,500 barrels (domestic crude 4m barrels 1869, 10m barrels 1873).
  • At peak oil boom, PA wells produced one third of world’s oil, pond freshets, led to railroad development
  • Subsequent booms in Texas, Oklahoma, California, John D. Rockefeller
  • Labor laws, strikes, monopolies, social impacts

Phase 5: The After Effects

  • Local environmental effects left from abandoned oil wells, done before environmental laws or documented on records (gas leaks, unstable earth, NETL map project, groundwater and soil contamination)
  • Climate change and soil, water, and air pollution on a global scale
  • Social Impacts (current impact job market)

Phase 6: Stewardship

  • Effects of Petroleum pollution on individual health
  • DEP, EPA, environmental regulations
  • Individual choices
  • Expansion of alternative fuel sources and their effects

Start of Article: Opening

I am a fries on salad, almost hit a deer every time I drive, haluski dinner, dairy farm heritage kind of Western Pennsylvanian. I grew up near Venango and Crawford County and had a pretty rural childhood. I went to an equally rural small school with about 300 kids in a k-6th grade school. My grade school years were pretty uneventful as far as normal childhoods go. Pizza days were awesome, sparkly stickers adorned worksheets, and field trips were king. Probably around 4th grade, I remember taking a field trip to Titusville PA. I remember seeing the familiar road signs and buildings as our bus gassed along the back roads. I had family in the Titusville and Oil City area, so it was a common route to take with my parents. If I’m being honest, I always remembered thinking that the area looked dilapidated and just, well tired. But at that point I was too young to know how different that area would have looked 100 years ago in the same spot.

On that particular occasion were we heading to Drake’s Well. For adults not from the area and oblivious 4th graders like me, Drake’s Well was the first commercial oil well in the United States.

12/1/20 Final Video and Next Video Process Work

Final Video Herd Immunity

Process Work for Petroleum Timeline/Drake’s Well

I think the overall outline will look as follows.

  1. How PA was formed
  2. How Petroleum was formed
  3. Early Petroleum discoveries/uses
  4. Petroleum explosion/Drake’s Well
  5. How it affected the world
  6. Lead into potential new technologies that will effect the world

I imagine this video will probably end up being a little longer than the Herd Immunity video. At this time, I foresee 2–4 minutes. I will try to touch each outline topic, while keeping it brief.

For the geology of PA I plan on hitting just the major events in the geology, as their is too much for a brief video. I will talk about the how the continents moved to form the area we now currently know as PA, and how a large mountain building event took place creating the Appalachian Mountains. Most of Western PA geology can be summed up as the Appalachian Mountains slowly eroding over millions of years creating a sedimentary basin which covers a large amount of PA. Because a lot of PA is sedimentary, these rocks hold organics, which turn into oil and gas over time and pressure. This will lead into the early discoveries and uses of petroleum, and how it was primarily a by-product in other extractions, and ultimately into the first commercial oil well Drake’s Well. I will then talk about the expansive use of fossil fuels and how we got to where we are today, and how it has effected our world. I would like to finish the video by talking about the new technologies that have the potential to change the world the way that fossil fuels did.

I am planning on trying to not be negative and harp on how negative fossil fuels are for the environment. I want the videos purpose to be more educational on just the history of fossil fuels, and just state the effects on the environment in more of a matter of fact presentation, instead of opinionated.

For the article, I plan on writing about my experiences growing up with family and Titusville and how I saw the rise and decline of the area, and talk about the field trips we’d take in school to learn about Drake’s Well. I will then lead into the topics from the video outline in more detail in the article.

For my sources I am primarily using DCNR educational materials, and a publication I received as a student on the entire geologic history of PA from the PA Geologic Survey.

Primary sources:

http://elibrary.dcnr.pa.gov/GetDocument?docId=1752499&DocName=ES4_GeoStory_Pa.pdf

http://elibrary.dcnr.pa.gov/GetDocument?docId=1752503&DocName=ES8_Oil-Gas_Pa.pdf

and

“The Geology of Pennsylvania” special publication by the Pennsylvania Geologic Survey

Style Choices

Stylistically, I am currently struggling with how I want to progress with the art and design for this piece. I feel like I could see it being done in one of the three styles below. Today I’d like to have a discussion about which one we think is the best to proceed with.

For the marker look, I feel like this would set up a more educational environment for the piece, since it is reminiscent of classroom white boards.

Similar, to this, would be the style of a stop motion video that I had created in the past with marker and paper cutouts.

I could also see the piece being completed with simple paper cutouts and stop motion animation to show the moving geology.

I could also see the video being done with background watercolor illustrations, with layers of separate pieces of watercolors that can have simple motions added to them for interest.

Concept Map

After creating the concept map, I don’t know if it makes since to explain more petroleum terminology? Something to talk about today.

11/23/20 Updated Video with Captions and Intro

This is the newest video version with the CMNH intro and the added captions. I also fixed some minor animation sequencing.

For some reason there is duplicate text appearing at the top of the video? I sent a copy of the video to my motion design professor asking about it.

11/19/20 Updated Video

For publication the video still needs to be captioned, and I would like to fix a random sped up section, but otherwise I am considering it done. I plan on having the video completely ready by this Friday.

I also accepted the article changes today and my article was published on the museum blog today.

11/17/20

For today I have a full draft version of the Herd Immunity video completed for critique.

11/12/20 Conceptual Questions for Anthropocene Topic

My next project will give a timeline of the geology of PA and how oil became deposited there. It will then go over the discovery of oil at Drake’s Well and how that has affected the world today.

These are conceptual questions that Asia Ward asked me to consider when forming my next project.

On top of these questions I did meet with animation professor Jeremy Galante today and he critiqued my Herd Immunity video so that I could work on some edits over the weekend.

  1. Awareness or knowledge: is there an acquisition of implicit knowledge? Is there a conceptual change? I think there would be more of a conceptual change. Because the video would show how one well caused the oil boom in the United States, and ultimately affected the environment of our whole planet.
  2. Engagement or interest: The degree to which we are interested in something influences how we learn about it, additionally informal institutions are places for generating personal interests. When writing the article, I hope to be able to engage more interest in the story by talking about my personal experiences growing up near Drake’s Well and going on field trips there as well. When it comes to the video, I am hoping that the hand drawn art style look sparks interest in the video.
  3. Attitudes: Is there a change in long-term perspectives towards something? Like increasing self-confidence, or attitude towards future career possibilities? The beginning of the video could lead to an interest in geological sciences by talking about the evolving earth and formation of PA oil. The long-term perspectives could be more about how one thing, or one action has the potential to lead to a world changing experience.
  4. Behavior and skills: Is there a change in behavior and thinking skills? The development of critical thinking skills? For example, the inquiry process of asking questions, explore ideas, experiment, apply their ideas, make predictions, draw conclusions, and provide evidence to support their thinking? I think I touched on this in the previous question, but I think it will emphasize that one action can change the world. It may even lead to individuals thinking about how their own actions affect the environment around them. It could also make people wonder about how other parts of the world were formed and affected by the changing geology of the planet over time.
  5. Learning identities: Do visitors come to see themselves as learners, someone who knows about, and sometimes contributes to science? I think the general audience would see themselves as learners, but people from western PA may see themselves as someone who knows about the topic and perhaps just learns a few additional things they were not aware of.

11/10/20 Progress Herd Immunity & Future Projects

Yesterday I had a meeting with Elaina Seep the CEO of Aniwahya Consulting Services. We started the conversation on what missions or topics the Tribes might want to share with the museum and general public. In the near future I will have more information and audio to help with different videos on Tribal experiences.

For this week, I have been progressing with Herd Immunity. I made all of the changes suggested by Asia Ward in our previous meeting. I am also meeting with my animation professor Jeremy Galante tomorrow evening to fine tune my cow character rigging’s and animations for the final video. I now just have to re-create the ending that Myra Kunas suggested in our meeting together this weekend.

Here is the current video.

In my last post I wrote about the next video topic I would like to pursue. Expect research and initial sketches on Thursday.

11/05/20 Meeting with Myra Kunas and Next Topic

Myra Kunas Meeting

I was able to meet with Interim Lab Director of the Minnesota Department of Health, Myra Kunas, this week.

We started the meeting by briefly going over my current Herd Immunity video. She suggested adding a portion showing a smaller cow to represent a “weaker” individual who cannot get vaccinations for health reasons, and having a group of cows surrounding that cow showing how they’re vaccinations protect the weaker cow.

After we talked about my video, I asked her if there were any topics she thinks would be important to create a video for.

She talked about how the biggest problem she thinks right now is a large amount of the population not understanding science; and about how they are a population that does not want to be reached. So, how do you reach a population that does not want to be reached?

We then talked about how it’s important to create content for younger generations since they are still open to learning science and being exposed to critical thinking.

The main point I took away from our meeting is that the topic of my videos is not as near as important as how they are structured. For instance, my videos should always start with a focus that zooms out and shows how things are connected and how everything is affected by individual actions. This just emphasizes the importance or representing the Anthropocene topics in each video.

Herd Immunity Update

I plan on finishing the Herd Immunity video this weekend, for Asia to give more critiques on in our Tuesday meeting. I will then make the necessary corrections and meet with Jeremy Galante as well this coming week to fine tune the character rigging animations on the cows.

Possible Next Article

This week in my meeting with Asia Ward we talked about wanting to create an in depth video about Native American health care. We decided that I should hold off on this topic until winter break, when I would have more access to the CEO of Aniwahya Consulting Services Elaina Seep, and Mary Wolfe of the Greater Lakes Inter Tribal Council. The goal would be to create a longer video that has videos and voiceovers provided by Mary Wolfe talking about her family’s experiences. I plan on talking about this project in depth when I meet with Elaina Seep next week to talk about the potential of the project and how to get it approved to meet the standards of Tribal members.

Because I will need to wait awhile to create this video, we decided it would be best to think of a project to do before this one.

I went over our first list of topics that we created when I started the internship. I decided that my next video could be on the geologic evolution of PA, and how it became the birthplace of the oil industry.

Asia had suggested this topic back in one of our first meetings. I think it would be a good use of my geologic background, as well as being able to connect it to the Human Systems and interconnectedness with our environment in the Antropocene’s list of values. Geology aside, I actually grew up near the birthplace of the oil industry and still have a lot of family that lives near there; so this topic would also be interesting to me on a personal level.

While herd immunity was aimed at a younger demographic, I think I would like this one to be more all ages friendly. In my initial brainstorming I see this video being in more of an illustration style, with subtle motions and kinetic typography overlaid to lead the viewers throughout the story. This video would rely more on digital paintings than vector drawings in the previous video.

11/03/20 Video Progress & Article Draft #6

So far this week has had a lot of video progress. I redid the audio VoiceOver, added a new background track, and also added the tertiary sounds to go along with the video. I tweaked the color scheme of the video and rigged the vector cow so that I could add him and the herd animated throughout the video. I have made it about 40s into the video so far. I hope to have the video completed by Friday. I plan on meeting with my animation professor again at the end of the week to have him help me with some animation tweaks to help clean up the cow motions.

Video Progress

Article Draft #6

When is getting an infection actually a good or a bad thing? Let’s start by talking about herd immunity. What exactly is it, and why have we been hearing about it so much during covid?

Herd Immunity, as described by the CDC is a situation in which a sufficient proportion of a population is immune to an infectious disease (through vaccination and/or prior illness) to make its spread from person to person unlikely. When a group has a high enough percentage of immunity in its population, transmission becomes increasingly difficult for a disease to spread to even the more immune compromised members of the community.

Although, herd immunity is obtained at different levels of community immunity depending on the disease. Some highly infectious diseases, such as measles, require about 94% herd immunity to stop community spread. According to the MayoClinic, about 70% of the US population would need to have immunity from Covid to stop our current pandemic.

So how do we even get herd immunity? Well we can achieve herd immunity through two different methods. The first method is infection. Herd immunity can be achieved by having a large amount of the population getting the virus naturally. The downside of this method is that the population has to get sick and recover. Depending on the disease, short or long-term side effects or mortality rate can be very detrimental to the population.

Germs have most likely existed for around 3.5 billion years (the age of the oldest living organisms, bacteria). Modern humans have only been around for about 130,000 years. Humans have only been around for a fraction of the time diseases have, but they are both a part of nature. However in response to their presence, human’s have developed immune systems that have been a part of a back and forth protecting us from harmful germs.Terrestrial vertebrates such as humans, have complex immune systems that have evolved to protect them from new immunological dangers. Getting sick is a part of life. Diseases have always been a part of nature, and that is especially true of the current time period, the Anthropocene. The Anthropocene is the current geologic age where humans have a substantial effect on their environment. During this time period, the way we interact with nature through contributing to climate change, deforestation, and urbanized life styles have increased the likelihood of pandemic-like illnesses to sweep over our communities. Deforestation causes loss of habitat; and with loss of habitat animals will be forced to come into contact with animals they originally wouldn’t have, including humans. This increases the chance for germs to spread to new hosts. Climate change and urbanization are also causing organisms to live closer together, allowing for diseases to spread easier through communities. So while diseases are a part of life and nature, occasionally there is one germ that can come around and have a profound effect on society.

I recently watched an exchange on the news between Senator Rand Paul and Dr. Anthony Fauci. Rand Paul tries to explain to Dr. Fauci (an expert of immunology) how herd immunity works.

This exchange starts with Rand Paul commenting on the declining rates of Covid-19 in New York City.

“…Or they’ve developed enough community immunity that they are no longer having a pandemic, because they have enough immunity in New York City to actually stop it.” -Sen. Paul

“I challenge that senator…In New York it’s about 22%. If you believe 22% is herd immunity, I believe you’re alone in that.” — Dr. Fauci

(If interested you can watch here: https://youtu.be/Yk2p2oyXxTc.)

The problem with this exchange is that the person who doesn’t have an understanding of herd immunity, is also the one who has the power to implement policies to combat a pandemic virus. Frankly, 22% is very low in terms of herd immunity. I remember the news stories when NYC was first getting taken over from Covid. Medical personnel lacking PPE, hospitals overflowing, using ice trucks to store the deceased, and exhausted nurses and doctors. All of that resulted in just 22% herd immunity. At 22% herd immunity most of the population of NYC is still susceptible to Covid. If natural infection was the only way forward, so many more of NYC’s citizens would die or become severely ill. However, because this happened NYC was quick to understand the importance of instituting mitigating measures to slow the spread of the disease. Andrew Cuomo, the governor of New York, is similar to Rand Paul in that he is in a position that he can implement policies. When he saw what was happening in his state, he listened to the scientists and applied their suggestions for closures, social distancing, masks, etc. As a result, the rates in NYC decreased. Not because of herd immunity, but because of serious measures against Covid. If we look at a different state, such as Florida, that did not take measures against Covid seriously, there were consecutive days in the state where they were having 10,000 to 15,000 new cases a day. This lacking approach to Covid caused thousands of preventable deaths. Even after months of lockdown the US is not close to herd immunity. All of the preventable deaths and long term health complications that I’m seeing in people are going to continue with the natural spread. This is why the global race for a vaccine is so important.

The second method of reaching herd immunity is through vaccinations. By developing a vaccine for an infectious disease, we are able to reach herd immunity without having to subject our population, community, and families to the side effects and overall awful experience of falling ill. By using widespread vaccinations, we can also protect our most vulnerable members of society. Our loved ones in an older or younger age range, immune compromised, or those with allergic reactions making them unable to receive vaccines. Herd Immunity is a good thing. When we have a disease like Covid however, natural infection will cause crippling long term effects in what were healthy people, and hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths. This is why herd immunity is good, but it depends on the method used to obtain it. I want herd immunity through vaccinations that protect the population.

Immunity is an important part of preventing diseases in my home. Herd immunity helps me protect my family, friends, and people I come across every day. When paired with vaccines, I am able to protect more people in my community. I have a small child in my home, and older family members who I come into regular contact with. My family (my herd), and I get our vaccines and flu shots every year to help protect those more immunologically vulnerable members of our family. By doing this, my herd is creating a mutually benefiting environment where our personal actions protect those around us. The actions that we take to protect our family also protects the members of our communities and your herd too.

Humans are a part of nature, and so are diseases. Individual actions have a larger inter-connected effect on surrounding environments and society. The same thing could be said about the covid virus spreading through the country. Society as a whole needs to develop a larger scope of thinking about how the actions of individuals affect the environment and planet. The factors I mentioned earlier, climate change, deforestation, and urbanization, are keeping steady and increasing. If these continue as they are currently, we can expect more pandemic-like diseases in our future. And when it happens, society will have to come together again to figure out the best way of adopting herd immunity to combat the disease.

As for my advice for the rest of this year, think critically, look at scientific data, vaccinations work, and in the words of Mr. Rogers, “Real strength has to do with helping others”.

Glossary

Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS): A medical condition where the immune system cannot function properly and…

www.cdc.gov

https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/terms/glossary.html#commimmunity

Herd immunity and COVID-19 (coronavirus): What you need to know

Understand what’s known about herd immunity and what it means for coronavirus disease 2019 ( COVID-19). Curious as to…

www.mayoclinic.org

https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/coronavirus/in-depth/herd-immunity-and-coronavirus/art-20486808

Vaccines Protect Your Community

Did you know that when you get vaccinated, you’re protecting yourself and your community? This concept is called…

www.vaccines.gov

https://www.vaccines.gov/basics/work/protection

Anthony S. Fauci, M.D.

Dr. Fauci was appointed director of NIAID in 1984. He oversees an extensive portfolio of basic and applied research to…

www.niaid.nih.gov

https://www.niaid.nih.gov/about/anthony-s-fauci-md-bio

10/29/20 Update & Article Draft #5

The Interim Lab Director of the Minnesota Department of Health, Myra, had to cancel our meeting for this week, so we are currently rescheduling for another time to meet. However, I did get to meet with my animation professor Jeremy Galante at Edinboro University. I wasn’t pleased with the motions of my cow, so I had reached out to him because I knew he had done extensive character animations in After Effects. I met with him for about 2.5hrs. yesterday where he walked me through how he sets up his character rigging and went over some of his “best practices” when doing character animations in After Effects. I now have a much more fluid cow rigging that I will use while developing the Herd Immunity video over the weekend.

Article Draft #5

When is getting an infection actually a good or a bad thing? Let’s start by talking about herd immunity. What exactly is it, and why have we been hearing about it so much during covid?

Germs have existed for millions and millions of years. Humans have only been around for a fraction of the time diseases have, but they are both a part of nature. However in response to their presence, human’s have developed immune systems that have been a part of a back and forth protecting us from harmful germs. Getting sick is a part of life. Diseases have always been a part of nature, and that is especially true of the current time period, the Anthropocene. The Anthropocene is the current geologic age where humans have a substantial effect on their environment. During this time period, the way we interact with nature through contributing to climate change, deforestation, and urbanized life styles have increased the likelihood of pandemic-like illnesses to sweep over our communities. So while diseases are a part of life and nature, occasionally there is one germ that can come around and have a profound effect on society.

I recently watched an exchange on the news between Senator Rand Paul and Dr. Anthony Fauci. Rand Paul tries to explain to Dr. Fauci (an expert of immunology) how herd immunity works.

This exchange starts with Rand Paul commenting on the declining rates of Covid-19 in New York City.

“…Or they’ve developed enough community immunity that they are no longer having a pandemic, because they have enough immunity in New York City to actually stop it.” -Sen. Paul

“I challenge that senator…In New York it’s about 22%. If you believe 22% is herd immunity, I believe you’re alone in that.” — Dr. Fauci

(If interested you can watch here: https://youtu.be/Yk2p2oyXxTc.)

For me, this exchange highlighted the clash I am seeing in the country against the nation’s leading health experts and scientists in general. Some may argue that Sen. Rand Paul was an eye doctor, and therefore may have some understanding of biology, but his experience for a global pandemic cannot be compared to a health professional who has spent almost 40 years working as the Director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. Dr. Fauci has created research on some of the most well known infectious diseases including HIV and AIDS, Ebola, Zika, respiratory infections, diarrheal infections, tuberculosis, and malaria.

The problem with this exchange is that the person who doesn’t have an understanding of herd immunity, is also the one who has the power to implement policies to combat a pandemic virus. Frankly, 22% is very low in terms of herd immunity. I remember the news stories when NYC was first getting taken over from Covid. Medical personnel lacking PPE, hospitals overflowing, using ice trucks to store the deceased, and exhausted nurses and doctors. All of that resulted in just 22% herd immunity. At 22% herd immunity most of the population of NYC is still susceptible to Covid. If natural infection was the only way forward, so many more of NYC’s citizens would die or become severely ill. However, because this happened NYC was quick to understand the importance of instituting mitigating measures to slow the spread of the disease. Andrew Cuomo, the governor of New York, is similar to Rand Paul in that he is in a position that he can implement policies. When he saw what was happening in his state, he listened to the scientists and applied their suggestions for closures, social distancing, masks, etc. As a result, the rates in NYC decreased. Not because of herd immunity, but because of serious measures against Covid. If we look at a different state, such as Florida, that did not take measures against Covid seriously, there were consecutive days in the state where they were having 10,000 to 15,000 new cases a day. This lacking approach to Covid caused thousands of preventable deaths. Even after months of lockdown the US is not close to herd immunity. All of the preventable deaths and long term health complications that I’m seeing in people are going to continue with the natural spread. This is why the global race for a vaccine is so important.

Herd Immunity, as described by the CDC, is a situation in which a sufficient proportion of a population is immune to an infectious disease (through vaccination and/or prior illness) to make its spread from person to person unlikely. When a group has a high enough percentage of immunity in its population, transmission becomes increasingly difficult for a disease to spread to even the more immune compromised members of the community.

Although, herd immunity is obtained at different levels of community immunity depending on the disease. Some highly infectious diseases, such as measles, require about 94% herd immunity to stop community spread. According to the MayoClinic, about 70% of the US population would need to have immunity from Covid to stop our current pandemic.

So how do we even get herd immunity? Well we can achieve herd immunity through two different methods. The first method is infection. Herd immunity can be achieved by having a large amount of the population getting the virus naturally. The downside of this method is that the population has to get sick and recover. Depending on the disease, short or long-term side effects or mortality rate can be very detrimental to the population.

The second method of reaching herd immunity is through vaccinations. By developing a vaccine for an infectious disease, we are able to reach herd immunity without having to subject our population, community, and families to the side effects and overall awful experience of falling ill. By using widespread vaccinations, we can also protect our most vulnerable members of society. Our loved ones in an older or younger age range, immune compromised, or those with allergic reactions making them unable to receive vaccines. Herd Immunity is a good thing. When we have a disease like Covid however, natural infection will cause crippling long term effects in what were healthy people, and hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths. This is why herd immunity is good, but it depends on the method used to obtain it. I want herd immunity through vaccinations that protect the population.

Immunity is an important part of preventing diseases in my home. Herd immunity helps me protect my family, friends, and people I come across every day. When paired with vaccines, I am able to protect more people in my community. I have a small child in my home, and older family members who I come into regular contact with. My family (my herd), and I get our vaccines and flu shots every year to help protect those more immunologically vulnerable members of our family. By doing this, my herd is creating a mutually benefiting environment where our personal actions protect those around us. The actions that we take to protect our family also protects the members of our communities and your herd too. Nature can also be looked at as an example here. Bees are group animals, so are bats, cattle, wolves, etc. These communities are repeated in nature for a reason, there is a mutual benefit to living and working together.

2020 has been a tumultuous year to say the least. Australian wildfires, the growing socio-economic tensions of classes, a global pandemic, and the war on science just to name a few. But 2020 has also been a very divisive year in my community. I think if society is to heal and grow in the much looked forward to 2021, individuals need to take a step back from their individualistic mentalities and look at how their actions affect their surrounding communities and society as a whole. Think about what you have done this past week. How do you think your actions affected your family, your neighbors, or your environment?

Humans are a part of nature, and so are diseases. Individual actions have a larger inter-connected effect on surrounding environments and society. The same thing could be said about the covid virus spreading through the country. Society as a whole needs to develop a larger scope of thinking about how the actions of individuals affect the environment and planet. The factors I mentioned earlier, climate change, deforestation, and urbanization, are keeping steady and increasing. If these continue as they are currently, we can expect more pandemic-like diseases in our future. And when it happens, society will have to come together again to figure out the best way of adopting herd immunity to combat the disease.

In conclusion, trust our scientists, get vaccinated, and most importantly, take care of your neighbors, and we can make 2021 a better year for everyone.

Glossary

Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS): A medical condition where the immune system cannot function properly and…

www.cdc.gov

https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/terms/glossary.html#commimmunity

Herd immunity and COVID-19 (coronavirus): What you need to know

Understand what’s known about herd immunity and what it means for coronavirus disease 2019 ( COVID-19). Curious as to…

www.mayoclinic.org

https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/coronavirus/in-depth/herd-immunity-and-coronavirus/art-20486808

Vaccines Protect Your Community

Did you know that when you get vaccinated, you’re protecting yourself and your community? This concept is called…

www.vaccines.gov

https://www.vaccines.gov/basics/work/protection

Anthony S. Fauci, M.D.

Dr. Fauci was appointed director of NIAID in 1984. He oversees an extensive portfolio of basic and applied research to…

www.niaid.nih.gov

https://www.niaid.nih.gov/about/anthony-s-fauci-md-bio

10/27/20 Article Draft #4 & Video Progress

So far this week I have recorded the audio voiceover for the herd immunity video and chose a background audio track. I have also started the video so we can start to feel the style and flow of the motion. I have been having issues with my cows motion so I have also contacted my animation professor for tips on the style of the animation and character rigging I want the cow to have in its motion. Regardless, I plan on completing this video during the first week of November.

For this video I used Adobe Illustrator 2020 and Adobe After Effects 2020.

In our previous conversations we had talked about wanting to incorporate a Native American topic into the project. I thought that this current video I started and the research I had done for it, might interest the Anthropocene project.

Here is the intro footage and the script for this video.

Script

Many of us know the stories of the European settlers coming to North America in the 15 and 1700’s. They expanded, grew, and took over what is now the U.S. But what happened to the original Tribal Natives who inhabited North America?

Well if we fast forward a couple hundred years over broken treaties, forced removals, slavery, assimilation, and some unethical surgeries, we are now seeing the physical manifestations of long term societal trauma.

This generational trauma has caused an increase in certain diseases to become more prominent in their society by methylation. Methylation is when certain genes become more expressed due to stress in a population. Native Americans suffer from rates of disabilities 3–4% higher than the national averages of all ethnicities. On top of this, the Indian Health Services put in place by the federal government to provide health care for Native Americans only provides about 44% of the actual need. Most health care professionals are also untrained with how to care for Indigenous peoples, leading to a vulnerable population of elders and members with disabilities.

To help our Tribal Nations we need to start by building collaborative relationship with Tribal Agencies; and more importantly ask and then listen to the needs of Tribal communities. ​I have also attached additional research in case any of this information seems interesting.

Additional Research

Equity Through the Tribal Experience: Assimilation to Sovereignty.

a. What it means to have federal recognition, gives a Tribe their sovereign status as a self-governing indigenous nation within the United States.

Federal recognition is required for the majority of federal laws and other provisions to apply to a Tribe.

There are actually 12 Tribes in Wisconsin, the 12th, the Brotherton Tribes migrated to Wisconsin along with members of Stockbridge Munsee and Oneida nation, leaving New England as settlers were pushing westward. In 1839, Brotherton was the first Tribe to accept US citizenship. They were terminated, losing their Tribal status, in the mid 1950s during the Termination Period (which we will talk about in a few minutes). Brotherton was one of three New England based Tribes, including Stockbridge Munsee and Oneida to have been identified as being owed over $30 million in Indian land claims settlements, all three were also targeted for termination around the same period in the 1950s to 1960s. Brotherton has been denied reinstatement by the BIA who has used their acceptance of US citizenship in the 1800s as a reason the were dissolved as a Tribe. There is no dissolution language in the 1839 citizenship treaty yet Brotherton continues to petition for reinstatement.

Treaty Making

The actual first treaty was in the 1660s over land rights and boundaries. From 1778 to 1871 the US made around 500 tribal treaties, all of which have been violated or simply broken. In all of US history, only one treaty was ever broken by a tribe.

Assimilation — Make Indian people in the image of European settlers(cut hair, dress like settlers, learn English, give up religion and convert to Christianity)

The Indian Removal Act was signed into law on May 28, 1830, by United States President Andrew Jackson and initiated the federal removal of settled tribes from the southeast (think Georgia and the Carolinas) to federal territory west of the Mississippi (Oklahoma) This is the beginning of what most people know as the Trail of Tears, a forced march in fall and winter with inadequate food or shelter, killing thousands. Despite these deaths, removal was supported all the way through the next presidency to 1841.

Dawes Act (also known as the Allotment Act) in 1887 offered citizenship in exchange for disassociation from tribe, intent to destroy tribal communities and land ownership by dissolving tribe and breaking the lands into allotments. These allotments were then portioned off with some going to tribal members and much being given to white settlers

Beginning of boarding schools and attempts at religious indoctrination. Policy of “Kill the Indian, save the man” — Richard Henry Pratt Carlisle Boarding School. There were 10 different Indian Boarding Schools in Wisconsin alone, including the ones located in Hayward, Lac du Flambeau and Oneida. Last boarding school in the United States closed in 1973.

A three-year-old Native child sent to boarding school in 1945 would be a 75-year-old Elder. This means your Native clients are either direct survivors of boarding schools or an immediate family member.

Reorganization the Indian New Deal

In 1924, under the Snyder Act U.S. citizenship was granted to all the indigenous peoples born in the United States territories (which included former tribal lands under treaty). However, it only covered around 1/3 of the tribal population. The Indian Citizenship Act (Snyder Act) was enacted partially in recognition of the thousands of Native Americans who served in the armed forces during WWI. However, the majority of states did not comply and indigenous people did not achieve full citizenship until 1948 when Arizona and New Mexico were forced to comply by judicial ruling. Under the Snyder Act, the US reaffirmed the responsibility for the health and welfare of tribes and began the first funding set-aside for that purpose.

1934 Indian Reorganization Act — Passed under President FDR, Indian Reorganization Act ended allotments and included a policy of self-governance for tribes, now allowed to incorporate businesses and establish credit, enhanced healthcare, education and employment opportunities, some lands restored and new purchased on behalf of tribes recognized right to exist as a separate culture & tribal council formally recognized as nation to nation status with the fed government

Termination and Relocation (Assimilation Part II)

Starting in the 1950s, the federal government began terminating tribes of their federal status, stripping lands, provisions and ordering the collapse/disbanding of governing bodies. This decimated over a hundred plus tribes. Menominee and Brotherton were both terminated, only Menominee was reinstated a little over a decade later.

PL280 in 1953 — gave certain states, including WI and MN, state criminal and civil jurisdiction on Tribal land. Due to Menominee being terminated before and then reinstated after, they are exempt from PL280. This crossing of jurisdictions not only affronts sovereignty but it makes prosecuting certain crimes, such as murder and trafficking, more difficult to pursue in a timely manner. Recent efforts of feds recognize that there need to be federal assistance in missing and murdered Indigenous women

IHS created in 1955. Has never been fully funded and remains at around 44% of actual need. Does not include funding for LTSS/HCBS

The Indian Relocation Act of 1956 (also known as Public Law 959 or the Adult Vocational Training Program) was intended to encourage people to leave their traditional lands, and to assimilate into the general population in urban areas. Job training, housing assistance and other benefits were promised but not delivered, leaving many stranded in unfamiliar urban areas without resources. This is part of the large urban population of Native Americans.

Indian Self-Determination

The 1960s and 70s were the human rights movements and that included Tribes. Rise of the American Indian Movement (AIM) and other activists to promote equality for indigenous people.

Voting — Native Americans won the right to vote state by state. The last to win was New Mexico in 1962. The Voting Rights Act of 1965 helped strengthen voting rights but in 2018 North Dakota’s Supreme Court ruled in favor of a new requirement of proof of residency that prevented many from being able to vote.

Congress passed the Indian Self Determination and Education Assistance Act in 1975 that allowed Indian Tribes and Tribal organizations to acquire increase control over the management of federal programs that impact their members, resources and governments. These agreements are referred to as “638 compacts and contracts”

1978 was the year of big policy changes

The American Indian Religious Freedom Act of 1978 (AIRFA) (42 U.S.C. § 1996.) protects the rights of Native Americans to exercise their traditional religions by ensuring access to sites, use and possession of sacred objects, and the freedom to worship through ceremonials and traditional rites. A joint resolution of Congress, the Indian Religious Freedom Act of 1978 states that it shall be the “policy of the United States to protect and preserve for American Indians their inherent right of freedom to believe, express, and exercise the traditional religions of the American Indian . . including but not limited to access to sites, use and possession of sacred objects and freedom to worship through ceremonials and traditional rites.” As a joint resolution the act had no provisions for enforcement.

Title VI amended for Native American Elders in the OAA in 1978

Indian Child Welfare Act passed in 1978

Native children in boarding school could also be “bought” (see the letter) and were given to non-Natives as servants, housekeepers or for adoption without consent of the parents. This was not prohibited by law until November of 1978, meaning it was not in effective until 1980. (Share LDF’s story about the social worker Mr. Mitchell) These illegal adoptions still take place but more quietly.

As part of what can only be described as genocide, the IHS and collaborating physicians performed sterilizations on between 25% to 40% of the female Native American population, including on minors as young as 11. Most performed without informed consent of parents or even without patient knowledge. The result was an estimated population reduction of over a third of the tribal population nationwide as women’s ability to bear children had been eliminated.

Walleye Wars (Mary share about Greg Johnson)

  • I took this information straight from PPTS and researched transcripts from Aniwahya Consulting CEO Elaina Seep, and Mary Wolf of the Greater Lakes Inter-Tribal Council*

Article Draft #4

Herd Immunity

When is getting an infection actually a good or a bad thing? Let’s start by talking about herd immunity. What exactly is it, and why have we been hearing about it so much during covid?

Diseases have always been a part of our ecosystem, and that is especially true of our current time period, the Anthropocene. The Anthropocene is our current geologic age where humans have a substantial effect on their environment. During this time period, the way we interact with nature through contributing to climate change, deforestation, and urbanized life styles have increased the likelihood of pandemic-like illnesses to sweep over our communities. So while diseases are a part of life and nature, occasionally there is one germ that can come around and have a profound effect on society.

I recently watched an exchange on the news between Senator Rand Paul and Dr. Anthony Fauci. Rand Paul tries to explain to Dr. Fauci (an expert of immunology) how herd immunity works.

This exchange starts with Rand Paul commenting on the declining rates of Covid-19 in New York City.

“…Or they’ve developed enough community immunity that they are no longer having a pandemic, because they have enough immunity in New York City to actually stop it.” -Sen. Paul

“I challenge that senator…In New York it’s about 22%. If you believe 22% is herd immunity, I believe you’re alone in that.” — Dr. Fauci

(If interested you can watch here: https://youtu.be/Yk2p2oyXxTc.)

For me, this exchange highlighted the clash I am seeing in the country against the nation’s leading health experts and scientists in general. Some may argue that Sen. Rand Paul was an eye doctor, and therefore may have some understanding of biology, but his experience for a global pandemic cannot be compared to a health professional who has spent almost 40 years working as the Director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. Dr. Fauci has created research on some of the most well known infectious diseases including HIV and AIDS, Ebola, Zika, respiratory infections, diarrheal infections, tuberculosis, and malaria.

Herd Immunity, as described by the CDC, is a situation in which a sufficient proportion of a population is immune to an infectious disease (through vaccination and/or prior illness) to make its spread from person to person unlikely. When a group has a high enough percentage of immunity in its population, transmission becomes increasingly difficult for a disease to spread to even the more immune compromised members of the community.

Although, herd immunity is obtained at different levels of community immunity depending on the disease. Some highly infectious diseases, such as measles, require about 94% herd immunity to stop community spread. According to the MayoClinic, about 70% of the US population would need to have immunity from Covid to stop our current pandemic.

So how do we even get herd immunity? Well we can achieve herd immunity through two different methods. The first method is infection. Herd immunity can be achieved by having a large amount of the population getting the virus naturally. The downside of this method is that the population has to get sick and recover. Depending on the disease, short or long-term side effects or mortality rate can be very detrimental to the population.

The second method of reaching herd immunity is through vaccinations. By developing a vaccine for an infectious disease, we are able to reach herd immunity without having to subject our population, community, and families to the side effects and overall awful experience of falling ill. By using widespread vaccinations, we can also protect our most vulnerable members of society. Our loved ones in an older or younger age range, immune compromised, or those with allergic reactions making them unable to receive vaccines.

Immunity is an important part of preventing diseases in my home. Herd immunity helps me protect my family, friends, and people I come across every day. When paired with vaccines, I am able to protect more people in my community. I have a small child in my home, and older family members who I come into regular contact with. My family (my herd), and I get our vaccines and flu shots every year to help protect those more immunologically vulnerable members of our family. By doing this, my herd is creating a mutually benefiting environment where our personal actions protect those around us. The actions that we take to protect our family also protects the members of our communities and your herd too. Nature can also be looked at as an example here. Bees are group animals, so are bats, cattle, wolves, etc. These communities are repeated in nature for a reason, there is a mutual benefit to living and working together.

2020 has been a tumultuous year to say the least. Australian wildfires, the growing socio-economic tensions of classes, a global pandemic, and the war on science just to name a few. But 2020 has also been a very divisive year in my community. I think if our society is to heal and grow in the much looked forward to 2021, individuals need to take a step back from their individualistic mentalities and look at how their actions affect their surrounding communities and society as a whole. Think about what you have done this past week. How do you think your actions affected your family, your neighbors, or your environment?

Humans are a part of nature, and so are diseases. Our individual actions have a larger inter-connected effect on our surrounding environments and society. The same thing could be said about the covid virus spreading through our country. Society as a whole needs to develop a larger scope of thinking about how our actions affect our environment and planet. The factors I mentioned earlier, climate change, deforestation, and urbanization, are keeping steady and increasing. If these continue as they are currently, we can expect more pandemic-like diseases in our future. And when it happens, society will have to come together again to figure out the best way of adopting herd immunity to combat the disease.

In conclusion, trust our scientists, get vaccinated, and most importantly, take care of your neighbors, and we can make 2021 a better year for everyone.

Glossary

Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS): A medical condition where the immune system cannot function properly and…

www.cdc.gov

Herd immunity and COVID-19 (coronavirus): What you need to know

Understand what’s known about herd immunity and what it means for coronavirus disease 2019 ( COVID-19). Curious as to…

www.mayoclinic.org

Vaccines Protect Your Community

Did you know that when you get vaccinated, you’re protecting yourself and your community? This concept is called…

www.vaccines.gov

Anthony S. Fauci, M.D.

Dr. Fauci was appointed director of NIAID in 1984. He oversees an extensive portfolio of basic and applied research to…

www.niaid.nih.gov

https://www.mayoclinic.org/herd-immunity-and-coronavirus/art-20486808#:~:text=Even%20if%20infection%20with%20the,19%20to%20halt%20the%20epidemic.

10/22/20 Article Draft #3

For this draft, I replaced “we” with “I” and “my” statements. I also changed the order around so that the article topic was brought up earlier. I moved the original intro to the end to help this as well, and to bring the “I” language back at the end. I left some “we” language in the herd immunity description since it was talking about groups.

Article Draft #3

Herd Immunity

I recently watched an exchange on the news between Senator Rand Paul and Dr. Anthony Fauci. Rand Paul tries to explain to Dr. Fauci (an expert of immunology) how herd immunity works.

This exchange starts with Rand Paul commenting on the declining rates of Covid-19 in New York City.

“…Or they’ve developed enough community immunity that they are no longer having a pandemic, because they have enough immunity in New York City to actually stop it.” -Sen. Paul

“I challenge that senator…In New York it’s about 22%. If you believe 22% is herd immunity, I believe you’re alone in that.” — Dr. Fauci

(If interested you can watch here: https://youtu.be/Yk2p2oyXxTc.)

For me, this exchange highlighted the clash I am seeing in the country against the nation’s leading health experts and scientists in general. Some may argue that Sen. Rand Paul was an eye doctor, and therefore may have some understanding of biology, but his experience for a global pandemic cannot be compared to a health professional who has spent almost 40 years working as the Director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. Dr. Fauci has created research on some of the most well known infectious diseases including HIV and AIDS, Ebola, Zika, respiratory infections, diarrheal infections, tuberculosis, and malaria. The political distrust directed at my nation’s health experts like Dr. Fauci is frustrating and illogical. If I took my car to a mechanic with 40 years experience, I’d trust him. Why not trust an infectious disease expert with over 40 years experience about an infectious disease?

However, let’s go back to the term herd immunity. What exactly is it, and why is it a term that I am hearing more and more?

Herd Immunity, as described by the CDC, is a situation in which a sufficient proportion of a population is immune to an infectious disease (through vaccination and/or prior illness) to make its spread from person to person unlikely. When a group has a high enough percentage of immunity in its population, transmission becomes increasingly difficult for a disease to spread to even the more immune compromised members of the community.

Although, herd immunity is obtained at different levels of community immunity depending on the disease. Some highly infectious diseases, such as measles, require about 94% herd immunity to stop community spread. According to the MayoClinic, about 70% of the US population would need to have immunity from Covid to stop our current pandemic.

So how do we even get herd immunity? Well we can achieve herd immunity through two different methods. The first method is infection. Herd immunity can be achieved by having a large amount of the population getting the virus naturally. The downside of this method is that the population has to get sick and recover. Depending on the disease, short or long-term side effects or mortality rate can be very detrimental to the population.

The second method of reaching herd immunity is through vaccinations. By developing a vaccine for an infectious disease, we are able to reach herd immunity without having to subject our population, community, and families to the side effects and overall awful experience of falling ill. By using widespread vaccinations, we can also protect our most vulnerable members of society. Our loved ones in an older or younger age range, immune compromised, or those with allergic reactions making them unable to receive vaccines.

Immunity is an important part of how we fight diseases. Herd immunity helps us protect our families, friends, and people we come across every day. When paired with vaccines, we are able to protect more people in our communities.

2020 has been a tumultuous year to say the least. Australian wildfires, the growing socio-economic tensions of classes, a global pandemic, and the war on science just to name a few. While there are many things that have upset me during 2020, the spread of misinformation and the attack on science is the most upsetting. Science has shaped my passions and my path in life. I have always felt like the way forward in society is to follow the logic, reasoning, and data that the scientific process lays before us. When in doubt for all things, including herd immunity, listen to the data.

In conclusion, trust our scientists, get vaccinated, and most importantly, care for your neighbors, and we can make 2021 a better year for everyone.

*To see a more light-hearted description of herd immunity using an actual herd, click here.*

Glossary

Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS): A medical condition where the immune system cannot function properly and…

www.cdc.gov

Herd immunity and COVID-19 (coronavirus): What you need to know

Understand what’s known about herd immunity and what it means for coronavirus disease 2019 ( COVID-19). Curious as to…

www.mayoclinic.org

Vaccines Protect Your Community

Did you know that when you get vaccinated, you’re protecting yourself and your community? This concept is called…

www.vaccines.gov

Anthony S. Fauci, M.D.

Dr. Fauci was appointed director of NIAID in 1984. He oversees an extensive portfolio of basic and applied research to…

www.niaid.nih.gov

https://www.mayoclinic.org/herd-immunity-and-coronavirus/art-20486808#:~:text=Even%20if%20infection%20with%20the,19%20to%20halt%20the%20epidemic.

10/15/20 Style frames, Storyboard, & Article Draft #2

Style frames

I would like to stick to a simple primary color scheme because of the demographic for this video. All visuals will follow this color scheme other than our “host” cow, that will be present and walking through the video descriptions.

Storyboarding Draft #1

Slide 1: What is Herd Immunity? First, what is immunity?

*”What is Herd Immunity?” text, Herd drops down and words shift for “What is Immunity?”. Question mark rotates in towards text. *

Slide 2: Immunity is when you are protected and cannot get sick from a disease.

*Camera zooms in on the word Immunity. Immunity puffs out it’s chest and deflects germs. Slide moves to the left with speed marks for next slide. *

Slide 3: So…what is Herd Immunity?

*Our host cow is now visible waving from under “So…what is Herd Immunity?”. The question marks rotates in towards the text again. The camera zooms in on the cow as he walks into the next slide.*

Slide 4: Herd Immunity is when a large amount of people are immune, making it harder for a disease to spread to more people. If someone sick meets people who are not immune, then those people can get sick and spread it to more people. But if a lot of people are immune, it’s harder for the disease to spread. This means less people get sick.

*Cow walks into the infographic slide of the colored shapes of cow outlines. The outlines change colors to represent infection and immunity with the audio. The main cows reactions change with infection rate in the infographic.*

Slide 5: How do we get Herd Immunity?

*Camera zooms in on cows face in previous slide for his quizzical facial gestures and question mark.

Slide 6: We can get Herd Immunity two ways. The first way is infection. If a large amount of people get sick and get better, they are now immune. The problem with infection, is that some people can get very sick. The second way is vaccines. Vaccines are weak versions of the disease given to us so our body can fight strong versions of the disease without getting sick. Vaccines are a great way to reach herd immunity because people don’t have to get sick.

*Cow walks into another infographic of color changing cow shapes to explain infection and immunity with vaccines. The shapes “sneeze” to show difference in vaccination and infection with color changes. *

Slide 7: Why is it important?

*Camera zoom on the cow’s face again for his shoulder shrug*

Slide 8: It is important because it protects your community and family. If enough people are immune, it slows or stops the spread of diseases. This protect people who have weakened immune systems and can’t fight off diseases as easily as you or me. Immunity is an important part of how we fight diseases. Herd Immunity helps us protect our families, friends, and people we come across every day. When paired with vaccines, we are able to protect more people in our communities.

*Cow walks into slide to meet up with a herd that represents his community or family. He interacts with them while the audio describes the importance of herd immunity*

Slide 9: Credits and Sources

*As the credits and sources roll cows interact by waving from the sides or eating words from the credits.*

Article Draft #2

For this draft, I tried to include the “me” in the article and talk from my POV. I also tried to pose questions to the audience.

The Covid Times: Herd Immunity

2020 has been a tumultuous year to say the least. Australian wildfires, the growing socio-economical tensions of classes, a global pandemic, and the war on science just to name a few.

While there are many things that have upset me during 2020, the spread of misinformation and the attack on science is the most upsetting. We are currently living in a time where people actively ignore or purposely oppose our trained professionals and experts. What’s worse is that some of the people not listening are our representatives who control policies influencing the spread of Covid through our communities.

I recently watched an exchange between Senator Rand Paul and Dr. Anthony Fauci where Rand Paul tries to explain to Dr. Fauci (an expert of immunology) how herd immunity works.

If interested you can watch here.

For me, this exchange highlighted the clash we are seeing in our country against our nations leading health experts and scientists in general. Some may argue that Sen. Rand Paul was an eye doctor, and therefore may have some understanding of biology, but his experience for a global pandemic cannot be compared to a health professional who has spent almost 40 years working as the Director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. Dr. Fauci has created research on some of the most well known infectious diseases including HIV and AIDS, Ebola, Zika, respiratory infections, diarrheal infections, tuberculosis, and malaria. The political distrust directed at our health experts like Dr. Fauci is frustrating and illogical. If you took your car to a mechanic with 40 years experience, you’d trust him. Why not trust an infectious disease expert with over 40 years experience about an infectious disease?

However, let’s go back to the term herd immunity. What exactly is it, and why is it a term we are hearing more and more?

Herd Immunity, as described by the CDC, is a situation in which a sufficient proportion of a population is immune to an infectious disease (through vaccination and/or prior illness) to make its spread from person to person unlikely. When a group has a high enough percentage of immunity in it’s population, transmission becomes increasingly difficult for a disease to spread to even the more immune compromised members of the community.

Although, herd immunity is obtained at different levels of community immunity depending on the disease. Some highly infectious diseases, such as measles, require about 94% herd immunity to stop community spread. According to the MayoClinic, about 70% of the US population would need to have immunity from Covid to stop our current pandemic.

So how do we even get herd immunity? Well we can achieve herd immunity through two different methods. The first method is infection. Herd immunity can be achieved by having a large amount of the population getting the virus naturally. The downside of this method is that the population has to get sick and recover. Depending on the disease, short or long-term side effects or mortality rate can be very detrimental to the population.

The second method of reaching herd immunity is through vaccinations. By developing a vaccine for an infectious disease, we are able to reach herd immunity without having to subject our population, community, and families to the side effects and overall awful experience of falling ill. By using widespread vaccinations, we can also protect our most vulnerable members of society. Our loved ones in a older or younger age range, immune compromised, or those with allergic reactions making them unable to receive vaccines.

Immunity is an important part of how we fight diseases. Herd immunity helps us protect our families, friends, and people we come across every day. When paired with vaccines, we are able to protect more people in our communities.

In conclusion, trust our scientists, get vaccinated, and most importantly, care for your neighbors, and we can make 2021 a better year for everyone.

*To see a more light-hearted description of herd immunity using an actual herd, click here.*

https://www.mayoclinic.org/herd-immunity-and-coronavirus/art-20486808#:~:text=Even%20if%20infection%20with%20the,19%20to%20halt%20the%20epidemic.

10/08/20 Research/Article

Today I used my research to write the first draft of my article on herd immunity. I also did some research on how to write for younger audiences. I tried to stick with simpler language and shorter paragraphs. I also created headers to divide subjects. It felt a little awkward trying to write for a 4th grade reading level and any feedback would be beneficial.

What is Herd Immunity?

What is immunity? Immunity is when you are protected and cannot get sick from a disease. Herd immunity is when a large amount of people are immune, making it harder for a disease to spread to more people.

If someone sick meets people who are not immune, then those people can get sick and spread it to more people.

(I would like to include some type of simple figure here representing this)

But if a lot of people are immune (herd immunity) its harder for the disease to spread. This means less people get sick.

(I would like to include another simple figure here representing this)

Why is Herd Immunity Important?

It is important because it protects your community and family. If enough people are immune, it slows or stops the spread of diseases. This protects people who have weakened immune systems and can’t fight off diseases as easily as you or me.

How do we get Herd Immunity?

We can get herd immunity two ways. The first way is infection. If a large amount of people get sick and get better, they are now immune. The problem with infection, is that some people can get very sick.

The second way is vaccines. Vaccines are weak versions of the disease given to us so our body can fight strong versions of the disease without getting sick. Vaccines are a great way to reach herd immunity because people don’t have to get sick.

Immunity is an important part of how we fight diseases. Herd immunity helps us protect our families, friends, and people we come across every day. When paired with vaccines, we are able to protect more people in our communities.

Sources:

https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/terms/glossary.html#commimmunity

https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/coronavirus/in-depth/herd-immunity-and-coronavirus/art-20486808

10/06/20 Initial Research & Sketches

This week marks the beginning of production for my first video. It was decided that the first video should be on “Herd Immunity”. My plans this week are to create mind-mapping, sketches, research, and create a first article draft.

For today, I did my initial brainstorming in mind-mapping and sketches for some style decisions for the video.

Mind-mapping

When I initially began to think about the design for a project on Herd Immunity, I thought I wanted to use generic shapes or human figures (like the bathroom signs) with color changes on a grey textured background. However, when you google herd immunity you see very similar designs that follow this aesthetic. When I completed my mind-mapping, I thought, what if I actually made a video about herd immunity, using an actual herd? This led me down a path of wondering how I could do this successfully.

Sketches

When I thought about a herd, I almost instantly thought about simple vector cows. What if used simple cow illustrations with accompanying primary colors magenta, yellow, and cyan? This obviously led me to thinking about designing a video for a younger age range.

At first I thought this may be odd to teach a topic like herd immunity to a younger group (~10 yr olds), but the idea actually grew on me. There is a lot of content being created for adults right now about Covid related topics, but not so much for kids. Kids are also experiencing the pandemic and are probably left behind with understanding everything that is happening right now. While this video won’t be about covid directly, it stills explains terminology that is being used in relation to it.

For the next part of this week, I will work on my research so I can begin processing an accompanying script and article.

10/1/20 Meetings and Initial Topic Selections

This week had two progress meetings for the project.

9/30/20 @ 2pm

Meeting with Asia Ward (Anthropocene Program Manager), Michelle Vitali (Senior Seminar Advisor at Edinboro University), and Hannah Smith (Self Directed Study Intern)

Asia explained the goals of the Center for Anthropocene Studies and Michelle discussed how they interplayed with the expectations for the university. A possible collaboration with CMNH and Edinboro University’s Scientific Illustrations course was also discussed.

10/1/20 @ 12pm

Meeting with Asia Ward and Hannah Smith.

Asia and Hannah discussed potential topics in depth and how they could relate to the current museum’s scientific studies. And to always keep in mind, positive stewardship, and how it affects “you”.

Palm Oil: Possible collaboration with Jennifer Sheridan

Jennifer Sheridan studies amphibians and the depletion of rainforests, swamps, and river ways. She has studied the affects of palm oil plantations and sought ways to make them more sustainable.

Her input would be beneficial for creating a more focused environmental topic in the realm of palm oil and for approving the accuracy of the videos script.

Microplastics: Explaining the physical and chemical structure of plastics and their pervasiveness in our environment. The history of plastic may also be covered, as well as how plastic recycling is evolving. Also, how does microplastic affect our biology?

Geology: Asia and Hannah would like to explore an Anthropocene geologic topic because of Hannah’s extensive geologic background. A possible video showing the geologic history and evolution of PA, as well as how it became the birthplace of the oil industry was discussed.

Native American’s Healthcare Access: Hannah is currently employed by a Native American Nonprofit that helps Tribal Nations gain access to health care and funding for their elderly and disabled populations. Hannah will pursue topic creation with her boss the CEO of Aniwahya Consulting Services Elaina Seep, on potential Anthropogenic topics in this vein.

Herd Immunity: During today’s meeting, it was agreed upon that the first motion design video should be on herd immunity. The video will not necessarily be Covid based, but help to explain what exactly this term means that has been being thrown around in today’s media. Possible collaborations for this video include Myra Kunas, the Interim Lab Director at the MN Dept. of Health, and Joshua Smith, a microbiologist and CEO & Chief Scientist of Premium CBD Labs.

General important reminders for the project include

  • Help to visualize an invisible process
  • How are we a part of this system?
  • Make sure to list all software and tech used to complete each video during the project
  • Remember to upload all files to the museum’s Google drive
  • Weekly meetings with Asia on Tues. @ 11:15am

*Next week starts the process for the first motion design video for the Center for Anthropocene Studies at CMNH*

9/29/20: Research Topics Brainstorming

From October 2020 to April 2021, monthly videos will be created for CAS using motion design effects and software.

Videos should emphasize positive human stewardship and take “cautious productive struggle” into consideration. Videos should also “prompt to action” their viewers and be able to be completed in the home.

Potential Anthropocene Topics:

  1. Palm Oil: The depletion of rainforests due to palm oil plantations. It will include all of the products that contain palm oil. The activity could include teaching people how to tell if there household items contain palm oil.
  2. Fast Fashion: The negative affects of shopping multiple times a year to stay “in fasion”. How the fashion industry is the second most polluting industry, only second to oil and gas; also the human rights violations for the production of cheap clothing. The activity could help people identify the source of their clothing, or how to identify clothing with low environmental impact.
  3. Makeup: The unregulated makeup industry, and how that affects you. The activity can involve going to the pharmacist run EWG that rates the toxicity of makeup brands and items.
  4. Deforestation and Pandemics: An explanation of how deforestation can lead to future pandemics. The activity can involve forest certified materials.
  5. Herd Immunity: I’ve seen a lot of things in the news recently that makes it look like a lot of people don’t quite understand what herd immunity is. This would simply be an explanation of how it works.
  6. Predator Declines: How Predators are actually good for ecosystems and foodchains. For example, how sharks keep fish colonies healthy.
  7. Ocean Acidification
  8. Single Use Plastic/ Micro plastic: An explanation on the life cycle of single use plastic. The activity could be to identify all of the single use plastic in your house, or how much single use plastic you use in a week. How much of that plastic could be replaced with multiple use items. How does plastic pollution affect me?
  9. Natural Resource Depletion/ Overconsumption
  10. Water Crisis
  11. Meat and Climate Change: How meat processing contributes to climate change. How much meat do you eat in a week? A month?
  12. Antibiotic Resistance
  13. Pharmaceuticals in Drinking Water

--

--